XCOM 2 splits critics over its turn timers, and that tells you who it's for
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The turn timer is where critics split
Critics disagreed most about how hard XCOM 2 pushes. Many missions are timed, so a squad gets a set number of turns to finish the job, and reviewers read that pressure in opposite ways.
Destructoid's Nic Rowen said the timers themselves weren't too hard, but he called the game's nature "merciless" and warned it could turn some players away. He also found some early missions "disproportionately difficult" and frustrating. GamesRadar+'s Maxwell McGee liked the same design and said the timers and other surprises "keep tensions running high" on later playthroughs too. Eurogamer's Chris Bratt went further: he credited the timers with pushing players to take risks and play on the attack.
GameSpot's Mike Mahardy landed in between. He called the difficulty "fair" and the game brutal, but he also noted enemies that sometimes seem to ignore the rules the player has to follow.
The split comes down to one question: do you like being rushed? The timers are what made the game for some critics and what spoiled it for others.
Why the pressure pays off for the right player
The whole design leans into being outmatched. XCOM has lost the war and now fights on as a resistance force, and the combat reflects that. Enemies try to flank, exposed soldiers take heavy hits, and a dead soldier stays dead. The Guardian's Rich Stanton and IGN's Dan Stapleton both praised an enemy AI that takes every advantage it gets. Stanton argued this gave the game a forward momentum that Enemy Unknown lacked.
The game also gives the player new ways to strike first:
- Concealment. Most missions start with the squad hidden, so you can set up an ambush for a combat bonus. Polygon's Charlie Hall and Bratt both singled this out, and Bratt called it "satisfying".
- Five classes. The Ranger fights in melee, the Grenadier blows apart cover, the Specialist heals and hacks with a drone, the Sharpshooter snipes, and the Psi Operative arrives late in the campaign. Game Informer's Ben Reeves praised how well the classes are balanced.
- Procedurally generated maps. Reeves and Mahardy both said this adds replay value. Stapleton also liked the variety of missions.
Critics also praised the character customization because it makes players care about their soldiers. That is also why each death hurts.
The base is as tense as the battlefield
Between missions, you run the Avenger, an alien ship that serves as XCOM's mobile base. Critics found this layer nearly as stressful as the fighting. Hall said it lends "a great sense of urgency and tension to every decision". Stanton pointed out that resources and time are both scarce, so every priority you choose costs you something else. PC Gamer's Tom Senior called the experience "gripping".
The Avatar Project works as a doomsday clock. Giant Bomb's Dan Ryckert said it made him "question every decision", and Reeves wrote that the game has you "second-guessing all your choices".
There was one dissent. McGee found the Dark Events "passive and indirect" and felt the alien threat was rarely felt on the strategy side.
Launch bugs were the other sore point
XCOM 2 had many technical problems at launch. Many reviewers ran into only minor bugs, but Rowen and Ryckert said the bugs ruined the experience for them. Firaxis later released a performance patch. The critic reviews describe the game at launch, so they don't say how much the patch fixed.
How to set it up for yourself
The game gives you room to adjust the pressure. It has four difficulty settings: Rookie, Veteran, Commander and Legend. After you finish a campaign, Ironman mode saves over your file after every action, so you can't undo a bad call. That mode is for players who already love the tension, not for players still deciding whether they do.
Players can also make campaigns, cosmetics and enemy types and share them through Steam Workshop. There's also a one-on-one multiplayer mode. Each side spends a pool of points to build a force, much like a tabletop wargame.
Sources
- Wikipedia: XCOM 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q20030150 wikidata.org