Analysis · Xenoblade Chronicles 2

Xenoblade Chronicles 2 split critics over a battle system few could ignore

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The same word on both sides of the argument

The sharpest split over Xenoblade Chronicles 2 wasn't about whether it's good-looking or well scored. It was about its battle system. GamingBolt's Shubhankar Parijat called the combat "intricate and addictive." The Washington Post's Harold Goldberg used the same first word for the opposite verdict, calling it "intricate, unfriendly gameplay" and saying he wouldn't play it again after finishing.

That shared word is the whole debate. The supporters and the detractors saw the same machine. They disagreed on whether all that complexity was a reward or a toll. Kotaku's Jason Schreier, who had also disliked the original Xenoblade Chronicles, called the game "overly complicated" and complained about "clunky" menus. IGN Japan's Hiroshi Noguchi saw "an incredibly deep battle system" in the same design.

So the useful question isn't whether the game is good. It's whether you enjoy learning a system that keeps stacking new layers on top of the last one.

What the combat asks you to track

Fights run in real time. You steer one lead character while two party members attack on their own. That sounds simple until the layers pile up:

  • Each character, called a Driver, can have three Blades active at a time, and those Blades set the character's class.
  • Blades and skills are tied to eight elements, from Fire and Water to Light and Dark.
  • Using Arts repeatedly opens up Blade Specials. Chaining those in order builds a Blade Combo that seals one of the enemy's abilities.
  • A Driver Combo needs four status effects in a set order: Break, Topple, Launch, Smash.
  • Landing a Blade Combo and a Driver Combo at once makes a Fusion Combo. A filled Party Gauge allows a Chain Attack, which hits harder when you break elemental Orbs.
  • An aggro ring shows who enemies are targeting, so you can lure them and pull their attention away.

On top of that, there are 40 Rare Blades in the base game, and most of them are optional. For players who like to collect and tinker, that's a long list of goals. For others, it's a long list of chores.

Too many tutorials, too little explanation

The complaints have an odd shape. Slant Magazine's Jed Pressgrove criticized how many tutorials the game throws at you, arguing that they kept pulling him out of the world. Yet Noguchi at IGN Japan said some mechanics weren't well explained. Both can be true: plenty of pop-ups, but not much clarity.

Smaller problems added friction. IGN's Leif Johnson found the minimap confusing enough that he sometimes got lost. Noguchi flagged a number of bugs at launch and expected an early patch to fix many of them. Even Parijat, one of the most positive voices, mentioned "obtuse design choices" and "a simple lack of polish."

Even the game's fans list its rough edges. The difference is whether those edges outweighed what sits underneath.

The story divides along the same line

The writing drew the same kind of split. USgamer's Nadia Oxford praised a story that takes on patriotism, war, environmental decline and refugees. She also pointed to the moral question at its center: are Blades humanity's partners, or its slaves? Schreier saw "an unsubtle script" that tramples its best scenes, and he criticized the pacing.

Length matters here. Johnson put the adventure at 70 hours or more. If the script works for you, that's a lot of story. If it doesn't, that's a long time to spend with it.

Where nearly every critic agreed

The music is the closest thing to a consensus. Nintendo World Report's John Rairdin praised it highly. Schreier called it "spectacular." Pressgrove, who disliked the tutorials, still approved of its "rousing soundtrack."

The world got similar praise. Instead of one connected map, the game spreads across several Titans that you travel between with fast travel. A day-and-night cycle changes quests, enemy strength and which items you can find. GamesTM called it the "apex of open-world design," and Schreier called the environments "beautifully realized."

The numbers reflect a game that most critics liked a lot and a few couldn't stand. At launch, Metacritic gave it 83% from 93 reviews. Its critic average of 8.1 is computed from critic aggregates. It also won awards at the 2019 Japan Game Awards and the 2018 Famitsu Awards.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet