Xenoblade Chronicles 3 split critics over its 150 hours, not its combat
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The argument is about the hours, not the fights
Critics largely agreed that Xenoblade Chronicles 3 fights well. They split on the amount of time it asks for. IGN put the runtime at around 150 hours and argued that a lot of it is filler. It pointed to an undercover stretch spent on menial tasks and a trek across the map to collect pieces of metal, and said its time often didn't feel "respected."
GameSpot read the same length as a strength. Its reviewer was well past 120 hours and still earning new Master Arts, leveling other classes and finding new tactics.
Both outlets are describing one design. The game keeps adding to its systems for a very long time, and it also pads the main path. Which side wins out depends on what you want from a long game.
A combat system built to keep paying out
Battles happen in real time. You control the lead character, the rest of the party auto-attacks anything in range, and you can switch between all six main characters mid-fight. Up to seven fighters take part at once, because a recruitable Hero joins the main six. The base game has 19 Heroes, and the DLC adds four more.
Every class fits one of three roles:
- Defenders draw enemy attention and block or dodge hits.
- Attackers deal damage and get bonus effects from position-based Arts.
- Healers heal the party, buff allies and debuff enemies.
Characters can change class. Class Points raise a class's Mastery level and open up Master Arts that carry over into other classes, and Fusion Arts combine a Master Art with a Class Art. On top of that sits Interlink, where the pairs Noah and Mio, Eunie and Taion, and Lanz and Sena fuse into invincible Ouroboros forms until their Heat Gauge fills.
Critics liked this side of the game the most. Nintendo Life called Interlink "easy to get your head around" and said it adds drama to fights. Nintendo World Report called it the best-balanced combat in the series and said its reviewer was rarely over- or underleveled. All those layers are what back up GameSpot's case for the long runtime.
One huge world, read two ways
The open world was the second big split. It is the largest continuous map in the series, with a day-and-night cycle that changes which quests and items are available, plus fast travel and optional navigation.
Game Informer found the zones lifeless and generic, without the memorable landmarks of earlier entries. Its view was that once you've fought monsters, gathered drops and recruited Heroes, there's little else to do. Eurogamer saw the same open space as a return to the freedom of older JRPGs, the feeling of running through "endless fields of long grass" with your companions. Polygon pointed to more than 100 side quests. It called their objectives rote but said each one showed how people live in Aionios.
Same fields, opposite readings: empty to Game Informer, freeing to Eurogamer.
The hardware split critics too. Destructoid called the game impressive looking by any standard. PCMag reported resolution drops, frequent pop-in and an unsteady frame rate as the Switch tried to keep up.
Who the length rewards
If you like to theory-craft, this is the easy pick. Swapping classes, building Fusion Arts and fitting Heroes into a party is the part critics praised most, and it is also the part that keeps going deepest into the runtime.
If you mainly want the story, the case is weaker. IGN's filler complaint lands hardest here, and Nintendo World Report felt the ending didn't fully resolve the plot. The game concludes a trilogy and depicts the futures of the worlds from the first two games, so series players get the most from it. Newcomers are better off starting earlier in the series.
Reception was strong. Metacritic summed it up as "generally favorable," IGN named it Best RPG in its Best of 2022 awards, and the critic average, which is computed from critic aggregates, is 8.9.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Xenoblade Chronicles 3 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q110875814 wikidata.org