Analysis · Xenoblade Chronicles X: Definitive Edition

Xenoblade Chronicles X brings its vast planet and thin story to Switch

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The odd one out in the Xenoblade series

Xenoblade Chronicles X first came out in 2015 on the Wii U. It was Monolith Soft's follow-up to the original Xenoblade Chronicles, and it broke from that game in obvious ways. You play a custom avatar instead of a set hero. A human ship has fled the alien battle that destroyed Earth, and the survivors build New Los Angeles on Mira, an open planet with five continents. Your avatar joins BLADE, the unit that defends the survivors and digs into the planet's secrets.

It kept several gameplay elements from the first game, but its structure belongs to Mira, not to a fixed cast of heroes. Journalists at outlets including IGN, Polygon and Eurogamer later counted it among the better Wii U games, and among the rarer ones. While it stayed stuck on that console, the series moved on to Xenoblade Chronicles 2 in 2017 and Xenoblade Chronicles 3 in 2022. The first game got its Definitive Edition in 2020. This one followed on Switch on March 20, 2025.

What the new edition fixes

Critics liked the new version a little more than the old one. The original scored 84/100 at Metacritic, and the Definitive Edition scored 87/100. The critic average, calculated from critic aggregates, is 8.8 out of 10.

Most of the praise is about the changes to play, not to the plot:

  • Nintendo Life's PJ O'Reilly gave it a perfect score, saying the changes improve gameplay and world design that were already great, and recommended it to new and returning players.
  • IGN's George Yang said the changes cut down on the original release's tedious parts.
  • Writing for Famitsu, Nishikawa praised the gameplay additions and graphical upgrades and called it a perfect starting point for the series.
  • Eurogamer's Catherine Castle said the gameplay and technical upgrades make it better for newcomers.

Video Game Chronicle's Chris Scullion was the coolest of them. He wasn't impressed by most of the graphical and story additions, but he still found the gameplay solid enough to recommend to new players.

What it kept: a huge planet and systems it barely explains

The core of the game hasn't changed. Quests come in four types: story quests, affinity quests that build bonds with your companions, small paid missions and side quests from people in New Los Angeles. Which quests you can take depends on how much of Mira you've explored, and that's tied to how far you've gotten in the main story. You also pick a role within BLADE, such as Pathfinder, Harrier or Prospector, and each one rewards a different way of playing.

In combat, your party attacks automatically in a set rhythm, and where a character stands changes how hard they hit. Most healing comes from the Soul Voice system, a quick-time prompt that heals the party or adds positive effects and raises morale. The Skell mechs arrive in the second half after a specific set of quests. They have limited fuel, can transform into vehicles and need insurance to cover repairs.

A recurring complaint from the 2015 reviews: complex combat and other mechanics that the game barely explains.

Not every critic minded. Eurogamer's Simon Parkin enjoyed working the world out without direct explanation. Polygon's Philip Kollar noted difficulty spikes, and Game Informer's Matt Miller felt the pacing got worse in later areas. IGN's Jose Otero praised the Skells despite the long quest line needed to earn them.

The story is still the weak link

The plot divided critics in 2015. Nintendo World Report's Donald Theriault liked the twists and the affinity missions. GameSpot's Peter Brown called the main story mostly forgettable, and GamesRadar+'s David Roberts agreed while praising the side quest stories. Kollar called the characters shallow and said they did too little to make up for a silent protagonist. Destructoid's Chris Carter summed it up as "serviceable, yet sometimes drawn-out".

The new story content didn't settle that argument. O'Reilly and Yang were mostly positive about it. Nishikawa, Castle and Scullion felt it made the game too long or added nothing new. If the plot is what keeps you playing an RPG, expect to come here for Mira, not for the plot.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet