Analysis · Xenoblade Chronicles X

Xenoblade Chronicles X builds a huge planet and a weak story to go with it

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for players who want a planet more than a plot

Xenoblade Chronicles X was made for the player who would rather map a strange world than follow a tight story. After an alien battle destroys Earth, a surviving human ship ends up on Mira, an open world planet with five continents. Your customizable avatar joins BLADE, the unit that defends the survivors from the home city of New Los Angeles.

For that player, it mostly delivers. The Wii U original scored 84/100 on Metacritic, and its critic average is 8.3 out of 10, calculated from critic aggregates. Players who need a strong cast or a gripping main plot will get much less out of it.

Where it delivers: the world, the fights and the Skells

Critics agreed most about the world. GameSpot's Peter Brown praised how much the game is built around exploration. Destructoid's Chris Carter called the world fun to explore, and RPGamer's Alex Fuller called the visual design "excellent throughout." Eurogamer's Simon Parkin liked that the world doesn't explain itself, and he enjoyed the challenges that came from that.

Combat also earned praise. Characters attack automatically, at a pace set by their weapons. Your job is to manage Tension points, a morale gauge and positioning, because where a party member stands changes how hard they hit. Most healing comes from Soul Challenge quick-time events instead of menus. Polygon's Philip Kollar and IGN's Jose Otero both named combat and exploration as the strongest parts of the game.

Then there are the Skells. These are transformable mechs with a walking mode and a driving mode. They run on limited fuel, and you fit them with new weapons in a hangar back in New Los Angeles. Donald Theriault of Nintendo World Report and Thomas Whitehead of Nintendo Life both praised how well the Skells fit into the game. VentureBeat's Heidi Kemps singled out the class system, where roles range from Pathfinders who open up new areas to Harriers who hunt giant monsters called Tyrants.

Where it falls short: story, sound and explanation

  • The main story. Brown and GamesRadar+'s David Roberts found it mostly forgettable. Destructoid called it "serviceable, yet sometimes drawn-out," and Famitsu pointed to pacing problems.
  • The cast. Kollar found the characters shallow, with too little personality to make up for a silent protagonist. Electronic Gaming Monthly's Jeff Landa missed the philosophical side of earlier Xeno games.
  • The music. Critics were split. Otero said it "just sounds like noise" and Brown flagged "low-rent tracks," while Whitehead and Theriault liked the soundtrack.
  • The teaching. The most common complaint was that combat and the other systems are complex and barely explained.

The structure adds friction too. Which quests you can take depends on how much of Mira you've explored, and that's tied to how far you are in the story. Skells don't show up until the second half of the game, after a specific set of quests. Otero liked them anyway but noted how long that quest takes. Game Informer's Matt Miller said the pacing got worse in later areas.

The side quests carry what the main plot drops

Several critics who were cool on the main plot liked the smaller stories. Roberts praised the side quest stories. Fuller pointed to how much of the world-building happens in side quests and the environments. Theriault gave special praise to the affinity missions, which deepen the avatar's bonds with party members.

That changes how to approach the game. Treat the side content as the main event and the story missions as a way to reach new parts of Mira. Players who rush the main plot will see the weakest part of the game and miss the best writing.

The Definitive Edition answered some complaints

The later Definitive Edition scored 87/100 on Metacritic. IGN's George Yang said its changes cut down on the original's tedious parts, and Nintendo Life's PJ O'Reilly gave it a perfect score. The story stayed the sticking point. Eurogamer's Catherine Castle still called it weak, and critics were split on the added story content, with some saying it made the game longer without adding much.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet