Yo-kai Watch 2 nearly doubles the roster but keeps the old grind
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Battles you steer instead of command
Fights in Yo-kai Watch 2 work differently from most monster-collecting games. You bring six befriended Yo-kai into each battle, and your job during a fight happens on the touchscreen. You rotate your team to bring different Yo-kai to the front, clear status effects off the ones in trouble and charge up their Soultimate moves.
The sequel adds the Yo-kai Watch Model Zero, which gives you two new tools:
- G Soultimate moves, stronger versions of Soultimate moves that use up the Soul meters of every adjacent Yo-kai at once.
- Poking, where you tap around an enemy on the touchscreen to find a sweetspot. One sweetspot makes befriending that enemy more likely. Others pay out extra damage, money or experience.
Food matters too. If you give an enemy Yo-kai something it likes before or during a battle, you have a better chance of befriending it once you win.
Collecting runs on chance, with a few levers to pull
You never quite catch a Yo-kai. After a battle, one of the defeated enemies may come over and hand you its Yo-kai Medal, and only then can it join your team. Food and Poking improve your odds, but there's no guarantee, so the whole collecting loop rests on that moment after a fight.
There are other ways to fill the roster. The Crank-a-kai gives out Yo-kai for in-game coins or the 3DS's Play Coins. Some Yo-kai come from subquests, and some can evolve, either by reaching a certain level or by being combined with a particular item or another Yo-kai.
The roster is the biggest change. The original had nearly 250 Yo-kai and this one has nearly 450, including several that were bosses in the first game. They belong to eight Tribes, each with its own strengths and weaknesses, and that's where team-building gets interesting. Legendary Yo-kai only become available once you complete specific sets in the Yo-kai Medallium, the game's record of every Yo-kai you've met or befriended. That target gives completionists a long-term goal beyond the main story.
A sequel that opens by erasing the first game
The story starts with a reset. Two evil Yo-kai steal the Yo-kai Watches of Nathan "Nate" Adams and Katie Forester, and both lose their memories of everything that happened before. They soon run into the butler Yo-kai Whisper and the cat Yo-kai Jibanyan again, their memories come back and the adventure picks up from there. You play as either Nate or Katie.
Like the first game, it's an open world you explore while hunting for Yo-kai. That freedom has limits, though. Certain Yo-kai are required to finish the main quest, so collecting is part of the critical path, not just something on the side.
Level-5 released the game in two versions, Bony Spirits and Fleshy Souls, as a Nintendo 3DS exclusive. It came out in Japan in July 2014, in North America and Australia in late 2016 and in Europe in 2017.
Why Japan and the West scored it differently
In Japan, Famitsu gave both versions 36 out of 40, with each of its four judges scoring the game 9 out of 10. That's the same score the magazine gave the original. Famitsu gave Yo-kai Watch 2: Shinuchi the same mark when it arrived in December 2014.
Western critics were cooler. They praised the game's charm and its much bigger cast. They also faulted it for leaving the original's problems unfixed and for padding out the quest. Bony Spirits sits at 72 on Metacritic and Fleshy Souls at 70.
The split comes down to what you wanted from a sequel: more of the same, or a fix for what bothered you the first time.
Psychic Specters did slightly better with critics and holds a 73 on Metacritic. If you're choosing between versions, it's the one reviewers liked most.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Yo-kai Watch 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21129987 wikidata.org