Yo-kai Watch splits critics on its errands, not on its charming town
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Famitsu gave it 36 out of 40 and IGN gave it 7.2
The biggest gap in how critics received Yo-kai Watch is between Famitsu and IGN. Famitsu scored it 36 out of 40, with all four judges giving it a 9. IGN gave it 7.2 out of 10 and summed it up in one split sentence: the gameplay is "inconsistent" but the world is "compelling."
The two sides agree on more than the scores suggest. Famitsu's Reona Ebihara praised a world that's "easy to melt into" and a feature set that keeps opening up as the game goes on. IGN liked the world too. The real argument is about what you do in that world from one hour to the next.
The aggregate figures don't settle it either. One puts the game at 76/100 across 59 reviews, and a second figure from the same 59 reviews reads 57%. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.6.
The fetch quest is the fault line
Even the warmest review admitted the weak spot. Famitsu's Urara Honma wrote that the game can feel like "one big fetch quest at times," then argued that the story's charm more than makes up for it. IGN was less forgiving, and that difference explains most of the gap between the scores.
The loop is built around collecting. The player character, Nate or Katie, searches the town of Springdale for Yo-kai using the 3DS touchscreen and befriends them by offering a food they like before or during battle. After a fight, a defeated Yo-kai may or may not come over and hand over its Yo-kai Medal. New Yo-kai also come from:
- a Gasha Machine that takes in-game coins or Play Coins;
- subquests that award rare Yo-kai;
- evolution at certain levels, or fusion with items and other Yo-kai;
- Legendary Yo-kai, unlocked by completing particular sets in the Yo-kai Medallium.
Some Yo-kai are required to finish the main quest, so the collecting isn't optional. For a player who enjoys filling in a compendium, that's the appeal. For a player who wants each quest to feel different, it's the repetition Honma warned about.
Battles lean on the touchscreen, not on menus
Combat is turn-based, but much of the input runs through the touchscreen. The player brings six befriended Yo-kai into each fight and rotates between them at will, tapping to clear status effects or to charge special abilities. Every Yo-kai belongs to one of eight tribes, each with its own strengths and weaknesses, which gives a reason to rethink the lineup.
Famitsu's judges liked this a lot. Ebihara called the system "simple and deeply strategic," and Honma said it felt "really great to control." IGN's "inconsistent" points the other way. Read together, the reviews suggest the battles suit players who like quick, active fights and may feel thin to players who want to plan every turn in detail.
The town carries the game
On the setting, critics hardly disagreed. The game draws on the yokai of Japanese folklore, spirits blamed for small mischief in daily life, and builds its problems around them. The player befriends the peaceful ones, fights the hostile ones and cleans up after the troublemakers, with the butler Yo-kai Whisper as a guide.
Springdale has a few rules of its own. During Terror Time, the player character is pulled into a nightmare version of town to grab treasure chests while staying out of sight. Get spotted and a powerful Oni gives chase, one that can wipe out the party unless the Yo-kai are very strong. Cross the street on a red light and a Namahage Yo-kai may show up, though following the rules can turn that meeting in the player's favor.
Those touches explain the praise for the town: it rewards curiosity and punishes carelessness in small, funny ways.
Who ends up on which side
The game is rated Everyone 10+, and the low frustration Honma singled out makes it an easy pick for younger players on a Nintendo 3DS. Players who already enjoy monster collecting will probably side with Famitsu. Players who judge an RPG by quest variety will probably side with IGN.
Recognition went beyond review scores, too. The Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences nominated it for Handheld Game of the Year at the 19th D.I.C.E. Awards.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Yo-kai Watch (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q21078995 wikidata.org