Yoshi and the Mysterious Book swaps eggs for borrowed creature powers
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every chapter hands Yoshi a new set of creatures to borrow from
The basic loop is simple. Yoshi moves through side-scrolling levels inside Mr. E, a living encyclopedia, looking for the creatures that live on its pages. Each chapter has its own creatures, and each one has its own traits. When Yoshi finds one, he can use its abilities to solve puzzles and get past obstacles.
That means every chapter changes what Yoshi can do. Most critics enjoyed that the most. Andy Robinson of Video Games Chronicle gave the game a perfect score and praised how many creatures there are and how much depth each one has. Heather Wald of GamesRadar+ singled out the game's naming mechanic and its sense of discovery. Destructoid's Scott Duwe liked that the game doesn't hold your hand too much, so you're left to work out for yourself what a new creature is good for.
A puzzle book first, an obstacle course second
The game sets you objectives and puzzles in each chapter, and creatures are the tools for solving them. The challenge is figuring out which ability fits which problem. Racing to the end of a level matters less. This makes it a different kind of Yoshi game from one about precise jumps.
Critics disagreed about whether that idea carries the whole game. Duwe wrote that it got better as it went on, which suggests the later chapters combine ideas in more interesting ways. On the other side, Ollie Reynolds of Nintendo Life gave one of the harshest reviews, a mixed score that called the game repetitive. IGN's Tom Marks was also mixed.
If the creatures keep surprising you, the structure works. If you get used to the pattern early, the same loop can start to drag.
Most critics landed on the first side. Famitsu's four reviewers gave the game 35 out of 40 in total.
Stop-motion pages with a deliberately choppy jump
The world inside Mr. E is animated to look like traditional stop-motion. Some actions, including Yoshi's jump, run at a lower frame rate on purpose, so movement has the slightly stepped look of a handmade film. It's a bold choice for a platformer, where the jump is the move you see most.
Jenni Lada of Siliconera called the game "unusual" and "experimental" and described it as an "entirely new type of experience." She meant that as praise, and it gives a fair idea of how the look and the creature system work together. This doesn't feel like Yoshi's Crafted World with a new coat of paint.
Short, kind to newcomers, and a little cautious
The biggest catch is length. Duwe called the game "short-ish," and no critic argued it runs long. It's single-player only, so co-op and versus modes won't add more time.
On the plus side, Robinson praised the game's accessibility, and it's rated Everyone, so younger players and people new to platformers can get into it easily. Wald was positive overall but said she hopes "[one] day[,] we see Yoshi get even more ambitious." That captures the general view. The game takes a fresh approach but plays it safe in how far it pushes that approach.
- Critic aggregates: 80/100 from 119 reviews and 83% from 123 reviews, with 82% of critics recommending it on OpenCritic
- Famitsu: 35 out of 40
- Japan launch: 39,661 physical copies sold in its first week, the second best-selling retail game there that week
Sources
- Wikipedia: Yoshi and the Mysterious Book en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q136231548 wikidata.org