Yoshi's New Island leans so hard on the 1995 original that it forgets to be new
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A sequel built on nostalgia
Critics kept coming back to one point: Yoshi's New Island is designed to feel like the original Yoshi's Island. It's the third game in the series, set between Yoshi's Island (1995) and Yoshi's Island DS (2006). Its plot, its moves and much of its structure follow the first game closely. You still play as Yoshi carrying Baby Mario, and you still flutter jump, swallow enemies and throw eggs.
For some reviewers that was the appeal. Alex Culafi of Nintendo World Report and Kathryn Bailey of GamesRadar+ both heard and saw the old game in its sound effects and level design. But Culafi also warned that a successor can only borrow so much before it starts to feel like a rehash. Edge pinned the nostalgia on a story that's nearly the same as the original's.
Gamereactor's Thomas Blichfeldt said it felt like playing "some sort of expansion" rather than a separate game. GameSpot's Tom Mc Shea went further. He argued that Yoshi's Island DS earned its own identity by letting you swap between babies with different abilities, while this game recycled its best ideas from the original and ended up forgettable.
Pocket Gamer's Peter Willington called it both "a great game" and one of the most forgettable Mario-related adventures in a while.
That split runs through every part of the game.
The one new idea gets boxed in
The headline addition is the Mega Eggdozer. You get one by eating a giant Shy Guy or hitting certain blocks, and it's a huge egg that smashes terrain nothing else can break. This is where the game could have stepped away from the original, and critics agreed it didn't go far enough.
- Famitsu's reviewers praised the mechanic.
- Kyle Orland of Ars Technica found it promising but said it showed up only in "extremely contrived situations".
- Eurogamer's Chris Schilling called its use "prescriptively and predictably" handled.
- IGN's Jose Otero felt the level design never fully committed to it.
The other new feature is a set of transformation sections. Yoshi becomes a bobsled, helicopter, hot air balloon, jackhammer, minecart or submarine, and you steer by tilting the 3DS with its gyroscope. Critics called these controls imprecise and clunky. Polygon's Danielle Riendeau and Nintendo World Report's Dan Koopman named the submarine stretches as tedious. A few reviewers also noticed a short delay when throwing eggs, mostly while standing still.
Sixty levels that split the critics
The island has six worlds, from forests to snowy plains to volcanic fields. Each one has eight required levels and two optional ones, sixty in total. Every level hides up to five flowers, twenty red coins and thirty stars. To open one bonus level per world, you have to collect everything and finish each level at full health.
That collecting is where the game earned its best reviews. Otero, Orland and Giant Bomb's Patrick Klepek liked the variety and placement of the collectibles, and Klepek praised "the satisfaction of exploration". Others found the levels flat. Nintendo Life's Dave Letcavage called them "average at best", Schilling noted their "sedative qualities", and Bailey found some linear and repetitive. Blichfeldt was harshest, calling the level design the worst in the franchise.
The difficulty follows the original-plus-comfort approach. Lose several lives in a row and the game offers Flutter Wings for endless hovering. Lose a life with those and you get a golden version that adds invincibility. Every boss goes down in three hits, which Letcavage called "shallow, simple, and uninspired". Two Famitsu reviewers disagreed and judged the balance fair, and Kiichi Totsuka thought veterans would find a welcome challenge.
A painted look that divides, a soundtrack that mostly doesn't
The watercolor art split critics more than anything else. Culafi ranked the 3D visuals among the best on the 3DS, Mc Shea called the art enchanting, and Willington said it "never fails to look beautiful". Famitsu's Tsumori Deluxe found the painted look and gentle audio soothing.
Others saw a pale copy of the original. Slant Magazine's Mike LeChevallier called the visuals vapid and stiff. PCMag's Will Greenwald found the effect "jarringly artificial", and Otero and Schilling both called the style inconsistent. Most of these critics agreed it lacked the flair of the 1995 game.
The music got little defense. Reviewers called it clunky and lackluster. Nintendojo and Nintendo World Report pointed out that many songs are variations on one theme, and Orland singled out the kazoos. Destructoid later ranked the game eighth of its 10 best Yoshi games, the lowest Yoshi's Island entry on the list, saying it "played it too safe".
Sources
- Wikipedia: Yoshi's New Island en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q11955502 wikidata.org