Analysis · Yoshi's Woolly World

Yoshi's Woolly World saves its challenge for players who hunt every bead

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for collectors and couch partners

This game was made for two kinds of player. One is the completionist who won't leave a level until every hidden item is found. The other is a pair of players sharing one screen. For both, Woolly World has plenty to offer. If you only want to reach the credits, it has much less.

Good-Feel, the studio behind Kirby's Epic Yarn, builds the whole world out of yarn and cloth again. Yoshi keeps the familiar moves from the Yoshi's Island games: swallowing enemies with its tongue and flutter jumping to reach high ledges. The big change is what comes out after a swallow. Instead of eggs, Yoshi makes balls of yarn. Throw one and it can tie up an enemy or knit an empty outline into a solid platform.

Critics liked it overall. On Metacritic the Wii U version averaged 78/100 across 83 reviews. Critics praised the art style and the new ideas and complained that the game was too easy. The critic average, calculated from those critic averages, is 7.9 out of 10.

Where it delivers: the look, the ideas and two-player play

The art style earned the most praise. IGN's Daniel Krupa found the game very familiar but said its imaginative look made it feel fresh. Nintendo Life's Thomas Whitehead called the visuals "gorgeous" and praised the "clever, witty stage design."

Co-op is where Whitehead was most enthusiastic. He called it "some of Nintendo's best co-op platforming." Two players can swallow and throw each other to reach spots that one player can't. Some sections also turn Yoshi into something else, such as a motorbike or an umbrella, which changes how a level plays.

The game also takes care of less experienced players without forcing easy settings on anyone:

  • Mellow Mode gives Yoshi wings for unlimited flight. You can switch it on or off at any point.
  • Power Badges, bought with beads collected in levels, add stronger attacks or a way to recover from a fall into a bottomless pit.
  • Any Yoshi amiibo figure adds a second Yoshi in solo play, so one player can pull off moves that normally need a partner.

For a parent playing alongside a young child, that mix is a real strength. The game is rated Everyone.

Where it falls short: the challenge lives in the extras

The main complaint was the difficulty. You can clear the main path without much trouble, so the test of skill sits in the collectibles. Every level hides five Flowers, five Wonder Wools and twenty Stamp Patches. Collecting all the Flowers in a world opens a secret level.

GameSpot's Rob Crossley, who gave it 6/10, pointed out that none of these items is required to finish the game. He argued that skipping them leaves you with the duller version of Woolly World and that it takes the harder route to be fully entertained.

If you don't care about finding hidden items, you'll be playing the easiest and least interesting version of this game.

Even the hunt had its critics. Krupa felt good mechanics kept getting placed in levels that never made the most of them, and that the levels focused more on frustrating collectibles. Apart from a few great stages, he found the game forgettable. Whitehead, otherwise a fan, called the boss fights "repetitive and disappointing."

Wii U or 3DS: the handheld version loses local co-op

The Wii U original came out in 2015. A 3DS version, Poochy and Yoshi's Woolly World, followed in February 2017 and averaged 77/100 across 56 reviews on Metacritic. Reviewers said the move to a handheld largely worked. Their complaints were about the downgraded visuals and the loss of local multiplayer, which Whitehead called "certainly a pity."

That missing feature decides it for co-op players. Because two-player play is the game's best feature, the Wii U version is the one to get if two of you will play. It works with the Wii U GamePad, Wii Remote, Classic Controller and Pro Controller. The 3DS version adds a mode where you play as Poochy, who can only jump and crouch, and a Yoshi customization mode. Both suit a solo player who wants to play on the go.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet