Z-A swaps turn-based battles for real time and confines Pokémon to one city
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A sequel to X and Y that never leaves Lumiose City
Pokémon Legends: Z-A is the second game in Game Freak's Legends sub-series, after Pokémon Legends: Arceus (2022). It's also a direct sequel to Pokémon X and Y (2013). It belongs to the ninth generation, but it goes back to the sixth generation's Kalos region and picks up five years after X and Y.
It doesn't go back to all of Kalos, though. The whole game takes place in Lumiose City. That one choice shapes nearly everything critics said about it: what they praised was built to fit inside a city, and much of what they faulted came from that same limit.
Battles now happen in real time
The headline change is combat. Earlier Pokémon games used turn-based battles. Z-A runs battles in real time, so it matters where the player character stands, where their Pokémon is and when a move is used. Pokémon can move around the field and dodge attacks rather than trading blows in a fixed order.
Two systems build on that:
- Mega Energy builds up during a fight. Players spend it to Mega Evolve their current Pokémon for a limited time.
- The Z-A Royale is a nighttime competition held in Battle Zones. Rival trainers wander these areas, and either side can open with a pre-emptive strike. An opposing trainer who lands one first can stun the player's Pokémon for a few seconds.
The Royale turns positioning into part of the strategy before a battle even starts. For a series built on menus and turns, that's a real shift, and it's the part of the game critics were most consistently happy with.
Critics liked the fights more than the city around them
Alana Hagues of Nintendo Life praised the battles and the game's performance on Nintendo Switch 2. She was less kind about how it looks, calling the visuals "lifeless and flat", and she found the Lumiose City setting restrictive.
Zackerie Fairfax of Dexerto made a similar point from another angle. He credited the game with good performance "but limited exploration and shallow side content", and his final word was that it's "ok".
The pattern across reviews: the new combat holds up, while the space it happens in feels small and underfilled.
The scores reflect that split. On OpenCritic, 65% of critics recommended the game, and its aggregate sits at 79/100. In Japan, four Famitsu critics gave it a combined 35 out of 40. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 8.0 out of 10.
Which version you play matters
Metacritic rated the Switch 2 version "generally favorable" and the original Switch version "mixed or average". Praise for the game's performance came specifically from coverage of the Switch 2 version. If you can choose, pick Switch 2.
Some things carry over from earlier games. Character customization returns with more options. There's also a multiplayer Battle Club with two modes:
- Link Battles, where up to 4 players race to defeat the most Pokémon in a set time.
- Ranked Battles, head-to-head matches for rank points that award exclusive Mega Stones at certain ranks.
Pokémon Home support continues too, with a catch. You can bring supported Pokémon in from Pokémon Bank, Pokémon Go, the two Let's Go games, Sword and Shield, Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, Legends: Arceus, and Scarlet and Violet. Unlike Arceus, Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl, and Scarlet and Violet, which trade back and forth with each other, Z-A only accepts transfers in. Pokémon sent into Z-A can't go back to those games, and Pokémon caught in Z-A can't move to older titles. They can only be used in Z-A, in Pokémon Champions or in future games in the series. Think twice before moving a favorite.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Pokémon Legends: Z-A en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q124672125 wikidata.org