Analysis · Zombie Army 4: Dead War

Zombie Army 4 is a sharp co-op shooter that doesn't pretend to be smart

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The best and worst lines describe the same game

The strongest praise and the sharpest criticism come from close together. Mark Delaney at GamesRadar+ called it a "consistently fun and frenzied" co-op shooter, with plenty of ways to play and reasons to keep coming back. Alex Spencer at PC Gamer called it "excellently-crafted" and then gave the warning that matters most: don't expect "much in the way of brains".

The two critics aren't really disagreeing. Both say the shooting works. Spencer just adds that shooting is about all there is. If you want a zombie game with a story that sticks or ideas that surprise you, that warning is the one to take seriously. If you want an evening of clearing out the undead with friends, the praise is aimed at you.

A shooter can be built with care and still be simple. Critics found this one to be both.

Scores cluster at 75, with a split by platform

The numbers line up with the quotes: mostly liked, rarely loved.

  • 75/100 on the Nintendo Switch, Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Microsoft Windows versions, each from 27 reviews
  • 75/100 from 119 reviews in a separate aggregate, and 72/100 from 11 reviews in another
  • OpenCritic found 63% of critics recommended it
  • The critic average, computed from these critic aggregates: 7.4 out of 10

The platform labels are worth a look. Metacritic called reviews of the Switch and Xbox One versions "generally favorable", while the PlayStation 4 and Windows versions landed in "mixed or average". The gap is small, but it puts the game right on the line between a solid recommendation and a shrug.

A 63% recommendation rate means about a third of critics didn't recommend it. Given the PC Gamer line, the likeliest reason is the lack of depth rather than poor craft. Nobody on record calls the shooting itself weak.

Friends make the case for it

The game supports single-player, co-op and multiplayer. The praise leans heavily on co-op. Spencer's verdict comes with the qualifier "especially with friends", and Delaney's describes it as a co-op shooter first.

That shapes who should buy it. With a regular group, you get exactly what critics enjoyed: a frantic shooter that keeps giving you reasons to come back. Alone, the main argument critics made gets weaker, and the thin story and design have more room to show. Solo players can still have fun, but critics didn't make as strong a case for them.

What kind of game this is

Rebellion Developments made and published it. It's a third-person shooter with survival horror trappings, rated Mature 17+. It follows the 2015 compilation Zombie Army Trilogy and is a spin-off of the Sniper Elite series, so fans of that series will know the studio's style.

It came out on February 4, 2020 for PlayStation 4, Windows and Xbox One, reached Stadia on May 1, 2020, and arrived on Nintendo Switch on April 26, 2022. The Switch version is among the better-reviewed ones, so that late port isn't the weak version some players might expect.

Set your expectations by the PC Gamer line. This is a game about shooting a lot of zombies well. Go in for that and the critics' praise holds up. Go in hoping for more and you'll likely end up siding with the doubtful third.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet