A city builder five times bigger than its predecessor, and slower for it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The whole pitch was more city
Cities: Skylines II rests on one idea: take the 2015 original and make everything bigger and more detailed. That means more land, more people and more systems tracking what those people do. Critics agreed that the idea is sound. They split on whether the game could actually run it at launch.
The numbers show the jump. The first game gave you nine tiles covering 33.1776 km2. The sequel lets a city spread across 441 tiles covering 171.33 km2, roughly five times the area. The original rendered around 65,000 citizens at once. Here, the only limit on simulated citizens is your computer or console hardware.
The deeper simulation is the part critics liked
The extra size would mean little if the systems stayed shallow, and this is where the sequel holds up best. Citizens no longer pick routes by distance alone. They weigh route length, cost, comfort and their own preferences. That makes traffic, the series' oldest headache, something you can actually reason about.
Several changes cut the busywork:
- Roads now lay water pipes and power lines as you build them.
- Police and fire stations can be assigned to specific districts to speed up response times.
- Service buildings grow through upgrades instead of needing a second building next door.
- New zone types include low-rent housing and mixed residential and commercial.
Time and weather add pressure too. Each in-game day and night stands for a month, and each map's climate brings seasonal risks: snow in winter, and floods, forest fires and tornadoes in summer. Telecommunications and welfare join the list of services you manage. Even IGN's Leana Hafer, the critic most troubled by its condition, found its new systems enjoyable.
Scale is also where it broke
The same ambition behind the praise caused the problems. The game launched on Windows on October 24, 2023, and the planned PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X/S versions were delayed indefinitely. Players' early reviews were mixed, and most complaints were about performance and bugs.
IGN said it felt like "playing a beta, or a very early Early Access game."
Ed Smith at PCGamesN gave it seven out of ten. He described calm early sessions that gave way to "supreme frustation and rage" (his spelling) and compared the launch to SimCity (2013). He also argued that something personal gets lost in the bigger scale. That cuts against the game's main selling point: a bigger map doesn't automatically make a city feel more like yours.
One detail became a joke among players. Every citizen's teeth are modeled in full, even though nobody opens their mouth and the camera rarely gets close. The developers said the teeth didn't hurt performance in any significant way. Still, the story stuck because it fit the wider complaint about where the effort went.
The repair job is slower than the build
Rock Paper Shotgun's April 2024 look back found performance had reached tolerable levels, with frame rates doubling in some of its tests. Stuttering remained, and it said more work was needed. Player opinion moved more slowly than the patches did. Most community reviews on Steam in 2024 were negative.
The first paid add-on, Beach Properties, made things worse. Three days after release, only 4% of its Steam reviews were positive. Players complained that it had few beaches and cost too much for what it added. The team apologized, made the add-on free, issued refunds and promised to fix gameplay before releasing more paid content.
Development has also changed hands. Colossal Order built the game, and Iceflake Studios took over at the start of 2026. Critics compared the game to a promise of what it might become. PCGamesN thought it could one day be the better city builder. That hope is the main reason to come back, and the reason to wait until you can see whether it has paid off.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Cities: Skylines II en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q116995799 wikidata.org