Analysis · Silent Hill: The Short Message

A free Silent Hill sketch that splits critics over how it handles suicide

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for series fans who'll take a short, heavy experiment for free

Konami and HexaDrive made Silent Hill: The Short Message for one kind of player: someone who has missed new Silent Hill games and is willing to try a small, free, story-led one on PlayStation 5. It was announced and released on the same day, January 31, 2024, as a free download. By May 23, 2025, it had passed 4 million downloads on the PlayStation Store, which shows how many curious players it reached.

The setup is simple. Anita Planert is a teenage girl who starts getting strange text messages from a friend who died by suicide. She searches an abandoned apartment complex in Germany for clues while a monster covered in cherry blossoms hunts her. It's psychological horror built on Unreal Engine 5 and rated Mature 17+, and it isn't trying to be a full-length survival horror game.

Where the dread lands

The kindest reviews focused on mood and on what the game suggests about the series' future. At IGN, Koji Fukuyama and Daniel Robson praised its "effective use of themes" to build "genuine dread". They called it a modern, impactful take on Silent Hill.

Christopher Teuton of Screen Rant went further. He called it "absolutely worth experiencing" as a free first look at where Konami was taking the franchise, and the best new Silent Hill work since 2014. He also added a fair warning: how well its themes work depends on each player's own relationship with them.

Even Polygon's Carli Velocci, who was critical, credited the game with "some unique imagery" that made her optimistic about the series. The cherry-blossom monster and the empty German apartments seem to be what stuck with people.

Where the writing and the chases fall apart

The complaints were blunt, and several came from the biggest outlets. They came back to two problems.

  • The chases. GameSpot's Mark Delaney called the pursuit sequences "trial-and-error" and the game as a whole a "bad Silent Hill caricature". If you play horror games for tension rather than repetition, that's the criticism to take seriously.
  • The script. Delaney found the plot and dialogue "on-the-nose". Kotaku's Willa Rowe called the themes "shallow and heavy-handed" and said the ending twist was easy to see coming.

Polygon added a fan's complaint: the nods to earlier games, including comparisons Velocci drew to P.T. and Silent Hill: Downpour, are "extremely unsubtle". A series that has often been praised for restraint is here accused of spelling things out.

The subject matter is the real decision

Suicide isn't a backdrop in this game. It's the center of the story, and that's where critics disagreed most. Rowe at Kotaku found the game "unnecessarily graphic". Velocci called its handling of suicide "borderline tacky" and said the writing doesn't give Anita much definition beyond her mental illness.

If self-harm or suicide is close to home for you, take the warnings in these reviews at face value before you download it.

IGN's reviewers saw the same themes as the source of the game's power. That split is the clearest guide to whether you'll get anything from it. The players who are moved by a direct, graphic treatment and the players who find it exploitative are both well represented in the reviews.

What the numbers say

Metacritic rated the reception "mixed or average". On OpenCritic, 31% of critics recommended it. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 5.7 out of 10. The game is unusually divisive, but it costs nothing, and that changes the decision more than the score does. You're risking a short session, not your money. Whether that's worth it depends on how much you want new Silent Hill material and how you feel about the subject.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet