A Sony mascot brawler where only super moves can score a knockout
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every hit feeds a meter, not a health bar
Up to four fighters share a 2D stage and move freely around it, closing in or backing off. Attacks come from three buttons, each paired with a direction. What sets the game apart is what those attacks do. Damage doesn't wear down a health bar. Each hit knocks loose "AP" orbs that fill a power meter at the bottom of the screen.
That meter is your only way to win. Fill it and you can spend it on one of three levels of Super Move, and only a Super Move can defeat an opponent. You can also grab orbs lying around the stage, or throw an opponent to strip AP from them.
- Level 1 is cheap but short-ranged, and it hits just one fighter.
- Level 3 costs a lot of AP but lasts longer, and it can take out several opponents before it runs out.
So every match turns on the same choice: cash in a small super now, or keep building toward a big one while everyone else is building too.
Why critics split on the super move rule
Critics generally liked the combat itself. The knockout rule was a different story. Some reviewers felt it made the game shallow. Others thought building the meter to land a kill added strategy to fighting that was otherwise only decent.
The presenters of Good Game, who each gave it a 6 out of 10, called the mechanic "flawed" and explained why. In other fighting games every hit makes some lasting progress. Here, a missed super throws away the last few minutes of work.
In this game, damage only counts once a super connects. Until then, every hit is a deposit you can still lose.
That's the main risk with this design. A careful, aggressive player can still lose everything on one bad read. If you like high-stakes swings, that tension is the appeal. If you'd rather your hits count as you land them, it will feel like the game is erasing your work.
Fifteen stages that change partway through
The roster pulls from Sony franchises including God of War, PaRappa the Rapper, Infamous and Sly Cooper, plus third-party guests like BioShock. The fifteen arenas are the most inventive part of the package. Each one mashes two games together and shifts from the first to the second as the match goes on, usually adding a new hazard when it does. Sandover Village mixes Jak and Daxter with Hot Shots Golf. Stowaways pairs Uncharted with BioShock Infinite. Hades puts God of War next to Patapon.
Items borrowed from other series appear mid-fight, such as the Hedgehog Grenade from Resistance and the Razor Claws from Ratchet & Clank. Both hazards and items can be switched off in the options, which lets you choose between party chaos and something cleaner.
The roster drew some criticism. Good Game's hosts felt several characters were chosen for their marketing value, not because they suited a fighting game. Even PaRappa's designer, Rodney Greenblat, was glad to see the character return but uneasy seeing him in a "weapon filled battle game."
Thin on solo play, and the online is gone
Arcade mode sends you through randomly picked opponents, then a rival battle for your character, and finally a fight against Polygon Man, the former North American PlayStation mascot. Critics knocked the campaign for using still images and having few cutscenes, and they called the package light on content overall. A challenge mode with set objectives adds a little more to do.
For longer-term play, each fighter earns experience in matches. Leveling up gets you costumes, victory animations and profile icons. Multiplayer offers timed, stock and kill-limit rules.
The online servers have been shut down, and cross-platform play between PlayStation 3 and PlayStation Vita went with them. Today the game is a local multiplayer game, so plan on a second controller and people to use it.
Where the critics landed
Reviews spread widely. IGN gave it an 8/10 and argued that it stands as its own game and even does some things better than the game that inspired it. GameSpot gave it a 6.5/10 and called it "competent at both" depth and silliness but the master of neither. It still won Fighting Game of the Year at the 16th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards and took IGN's People's Choice Award. The critic average of 7.4 out of 10 is calculated from critic aggregates, and it sits in the same solid-but-divided range as the reviews.
Sources
- Wikipedia: PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2523519 wikidata.org