Analysis · Ark: Survival Evolved

Ark tames dinosaurs brilliantly, then buries the fun under hours of grinding

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Studio Wildcard's one big bet grew up in early access

Ark is the game Studio Wildcard is known for. It grew in front of its players before it was finished. It launched in early access on Steam and sold over one million copies within a month. By August 2016, a year before its full release on August 29, 2017, it had passed 5.5 million sales across Windows and Xbox One.

Launch didn't stop the growth. Expansions followed, including Extinction and the Genesis releases, along with a season pass. Co-founder Jesse Rapczak said the Genesis expansions came about partly because Extinction and the season pass sold better than expected, and partly because he believed the story had room to grow. By June 2022 the game had 76.5 million installs across PC and consoles, and 38.4 million of those came from free promotions. That's a big reason so many players have it in their library.

The island stopped being a natural history museum

The biggest change over the game's life is what lives on the island. Early versions were stocked almost entirely with real dinosaurs and other prehistoric animals. As the story went on, mythical creatures arrived: wyverns, griffins, golems and a phoenix. Later expansions added original designs like the Karkinos and the Velonasaur, then robots such as the Enforcer and the Scout. The count now stands at 194 creatures.

That gives players more to chase. The trade-off is that the opening promise, a prehistoric island with its own predator hierarchies, gets diluted by unicorns and machines. Players who came for the dinosaurs may find the later content drifts away from them.

The other big change came on Nintendo Switch. Critics panned the first port for its low resolution and frame rate, blurry textures, low-poly models, crashes and long load times. Eurogamer's John Linneman compared it to a "poorly compressed JPEG" of a painting. A rebuilt Switch version from Grove Street Games, released in 2022, turned that around, and Linneman called it one of the biggest improvements he had seen. The "generally unfavorable" Switch reception describes the first port, not the rebuild.

The taming loop is what never changed, and it's the reason to play

The core has stayed the same since early access. You wash up on a map of about 48 square kilometers, roughly 36 of land and 12 of ocean. You build a base with a fire and weapons, and you watch meters for health, stamina, oxygen, hunger, thirst and carrying weight.

Taming is the hook, and it has real variety:

  • Most creatures are knocked out with tranquilizers or a club. Then you keep them sedated and feed them what they like: berries for herbivores, meat for carnivores.
  • Some, like the Moschops, can be tamed peacefully by approaching with food.
  • Others, including the Carcharodontosaurus, Reaper and Fjordhawk, need their own mini-games.

A tamed creature becomes your transport, your pack animal and your fighting partner. A brontosaurus or mosasaurus can even carry a building platform as a small mobile base. GameSpot praised the game's "outstanding sense of place and mood," and the creatures are a big part of where that comes from.

Critics kept hitting the same wall: the grind

The reviews agree with each other more than the scores suggest. IGN's TJ Hafer gave it 7.7/10 and called the good moments really good. He also said they come at about one part in ten, with the rest spent grinding and crafting, especially at the later tech tiers. He found that losing a boss fight and having to redo the work felt far too punishing, and that some dim-witted dinosaurs drained the danger from the world.

GameSpot's 6/10 made the same point more sharply. It cited how hard everything is, the huge amount of time needed to see even a fraction of the game, and random deaths that wipe out what you built. Ian Birnbaum of PC Gamer gave it 72/100 and called it "a bloated, grindy mess" with a better game hidden inside all its options.

If losing hours of progress to one bad death sounds like a dealbreaker, it will be one here.

The aggregates match that tone. Metacritic rated the Windows, PlayStation 4 and Xbox One versions "mixed or average," with each version listed at 65/100 from 11 reviews. A broader count of 53 reviews landed at 61/100.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet