Analysis · Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord

Bannerlord's battles deliver, but its kingdoms exist mainly to be burned

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A general who also holds a sword

Mount & Blade II: Bannerlord is built on the same idea as the rest of the series. You build up a party of soldiers on an overhead campaign map, then ride into each battle and fight alongside them. Critics agreed the fighting half of that promise works. They were much less convinced by the half about running a war.

Reviews have been consistent on that split. Reviews after the full release on October 25, 2022 praised the combat and the visual polish. IGN's Jon Bolding called the kingdom-management strategy "weak". That gap between the battlefield and the throne room shows up in every part of the game.

Sieges show the idea at its best

Sieges are where the campaign map and the battlefield work together best. Before an assault you can build several kinds of siege engine and position them to hit particular sections of a wall. On the campaign map you can bombard the walls ahead of time and open breaches to use once the fighting starts. During the battle itself, only merlons, gatehouses and siege engines can be destroyed, which stops an attack from turning into a long shelling match.

Castles and cities are designed to favor defenders. Murder holes often cover key chokepoints, so a careless attacker can lose a lot of soldiers before reaching the gate. The planning you do on the map changes what happens when you're standing in the mud, and that is exactly what the premise promises.

Derek Johnson of Jump Dash Roll said the game looks good, "sounds super and runs well, too." Multiplayer sticks to battles only and is separate from the campaign. Players pick infantry, ranged or cavalry classes with a point system, and each faction's strengths and weaknesses shape those classes.

Persuasion and family give the party a future

Outside battle, you build relationships through a more involved dialogue system. To persuade a character, you fill a progress bar by pushing your arguments, and each attempt can fail critically, fail, succeed or succeed critically. If charm isn't enough, you can barter items and animals, and with a certain perk you can also trade fiefs. Fail too often and the deal may become impossible, and the relationship can suffer.

The same system lets you court and marry. Unlike in Warband, you can now have children, and if your character dies, one of them inherits your soldiers and fiefs and takes over as the player character. That stretches the core idea across generations: the party outlives its founder.

The kingdom is a target, not a country

The full-release reviews found the problem in the strategy layer. Critics criticized the lack of depth in both kingdom management and diplomacy. Bolding described a busy map full of trader caravans, robber bands, war parties and peasants moving between settlements. In his view, though, all of it mainly exists to give you enemy property to raid, loot and burn.

If you want to rule, Bannerlord gives you plenty to conquer and not much to govern.

That is the clearest failure of the core idea. The battles feel like they matter, but the kingdom they're supposed to serve doesn't give them much meaning beyond the next fight.

Early access set expectations it never fully dropped

Bannerlord first launched in early access in 2020 and became the largest launch of the year on Steam. Early critics loved it while admitting its faults. Eurogamer's Chris Bratt headlined his piece "janky as hell" and still said he loved it. PC Gamer's Fraser Brown called it unfinished but brilliant. Kotaku's Ethan Gach called the action clunky and the world ugly, then said the game won him over. IGN's Leana Hafer called it ambitious and reasonably well polished, with a long way to go.

Later scores drifted down. Aggregates include 81/100 from eight reviews across all five platforms, 76/100 from 32 reviews in December 2022, and 68% from 35 reviews in December 2025. One outlet gave it 7/10. Critics forgave the rough edges early on in exchange for the promise of a full game. Once it shipped, the thin strategy layer was harder to excuse.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet