Analysis · Black Desert

Black Desert trades tab-targeting for aimed combat and a world run by weather

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Good averages hide a divided reception

The averages don't match the reaction. Black Desert's beta was well received. The full game got mixed or average reviews, and Metacritic shows a 73/100 average across the PC, PS4 and Xbox One versions. Vandal scored it 78%. One aggregate of 42 reviews put it at 71/100 but also carried a much lower 45% figure. That gap points to a split among critics, not a shared middling opinion.

The critic average of 7.2 is computed from those critic aggregates. It's a fair middle, but a middle made of people who liked the game a lot and people who didn't. The useful question is which group you'd be in, and the game's design answers most of that.

Combat asks for aim, not hotkey rotations

Most MMORPGs use tab-targeting: pick a target, then press skills in order. Black Desert doesn't. Its combat works more like a third-person shooter, with manual aiming, free movement, dodging and skills fired off through combos for attacking, dodging or blocking. You can also fight from horseback.

This is the biggest fork in the road. Players who come from action games will find fights that reward timing and position. Players who like MMORPG combat as a steady rotation they can plan out will find the game asks for something else. Neither side is wrong, and it goes a long way toward explaining why the scores spread out.

A world that keeps moving while you fish

Much of Black Desert has nothing to do with fighting. It offers housing, fishing, farming and trading, and players spend real time on them. Player housing is instanced and comes in different sizes and locations. You furnish it with pieces bought from NPCs or made through crafting.

The world runs on systems instead of scripts:

  • Weather covers the whole world and includes typhoons that affect play. Local fog can give guilds cover for surprise attacks on rival structures.
  • A day/night cycle changes what's on offer. Some NPCs go home at night, and monsters drop more loot after dark.
  • Mounts are tamed in the wild and can be bred for special types. They need feeding and care, can't go in your inventory and can be killed.

The mounts show the game's approach best. It's more upkeep than most MMORPGs ask for, and that suits players who want a horse to feel like their own. Players who just want fast travel will see it as a chore.

Sieges, characters and a crowd that stayed

The multiplayer side builds to large player-versus-player siege events and castle battles, with co-op play alongside. Character customization is well regarded for how detailed it is, which matters in a game where much of the appeal is living in the world.

Whatever critics thought, players kept showing up. Publisher Kakao Games reported 400,000 copies sold in the first month in Europe and North America. By September 2020, the game had reached 40 million players and grossed $1.7 billion worldwide. It's one of the most played games on Steam.

Check the price model before you start. Black Desert is free-to-play in some parts of the world, but the English-language editions are buy-to-play. It runs on Windows, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Linux, Android and iOS. The mobile version, Black Desert Mobile, is its own release.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet