Analysis · Call of Duty: Black Ops Cold War

Black Ops Cold War works best for campaign and Zombies fans, not lobby veterans

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who want a story and a squad, in that order

Black Ops Cold War is a first-person shooter for the Call of Duty player who still plays the campaign first and then heads into Zombies with friends. Set in 1981, its story follows CIA operative Russell Adler and his team as they hunt a Soviet spy named Perseus. Treyarch and Raven Software co-developed it, and Activision published it on November 13, 2020.

That player gets the best of what the game offers. The player who comes for multiplayer lobbies gets the version critics argued about most. Reviewers broadly agreed on that split. Metacritic lists a weighted average of 76/100, and OpenCritic reports that 61% of critics recommended the game. That's a modest share for a series this size, and the multiplayer reviews explain most of the gap.

The campaign gives you room to choose, then ends too soon

The campaign is the most unusual part of the package. You build your own agent by picking an intelligence agency, nationality, skin tone and gender, plus personality traits that grant in-game perks. Missions are non-linear and offer several ways to reach each objective. Between missions you return to a safe house, where you can study evidence, talk with other characters and plan the next job on an evidence board. Choices made along the way lead to multiple endings.

Critics responded well to that structure:

  • GameSpot's Kallie Plagge praised the open-ended levels and called a mission set inside a KGB building "a showcase for both stealth and freedom of choice".
  • IGN's Ryan McCaffrey liked the safe house and the character customization.
  • Game Informer's Daniel Tack called it an "enjoyable-but-short return to form" for the Black Ops sub-series.

The complaints are about depth and length. PC Gamer's Morgan Park found the best ideas, like the stealth missions and the conversations with other characters, "under-explored or fleeting", and said the plot ended abruptly. McCaffrey felt the story was weaker than the one in Call of Duty: Black Ops (2010). So you get a campaign that offers real choices, but it doesn't spend long on them.

Multiplayer is where the game falls short

On paper, multiplayer has plenty to do. Alongside standard modes like Team Deathmatch, Domination and Hardpoint, it adds three new ones:

  • VIP Escort: two teams of six, with one team escorting a randomly chosen VIP to an extraction point. The first team to four points wins.
  • Combined Arms: two teams of twelve on large maps with transport vehicles, fighting over five to six capture zones until one side reaches 400 points.
  • Fireteam: Dirty Bomb: ten teams of four collecting uranium to set off dirty bombs.

Progression runs through 55 player levels, and the Gunsmith attachment system returns from Modern Warfare (2019).

Critics kept comparing it to that game, and the comparisons mostly hurt. IGN's Simon Cardy gave the multiplayer a 6/10 and called it a step back in map design, visuals and launch content. Plagge called it "clumsier", pointing to features that were cut, like mounting weapons and switching a weapon's fire rate. The maps were the one area where opinion turned. GamesRadar+'s Ford James thought they improved on Modern Warfare's, and Hardcore Gamer's Kevin Dunsmore credited their three-lane design with keeping fights frequent and downtime short.

If you play Call of Duty mainly for multiplayer, the recurring complaint was that Cold War took away mechanics its predecessor had added.

Zombies is the easiest way in, as long as you have friends

The cooperative Zombies mode got mostly positive reviews. The launch map, Die Maschine, drew praise from IGN's David Jagneaux for its "layered" design and from Plagge as well. PCGamesN's Jordan Forward pointed to custom pre-game loadouts and enemy health bars as changes that help new players. Plagge called the learning curve "manageable" but warned that the difficulty rises quickly after the first ten rounds.

There are limits. Jagneaux docked points because there's no split-screen and some features from Black Ops 4's Zombies are missing, which means couch co-op is out. Video Games Chronicle's Jordan Middler said the mode "excels" with friends and suits long-time fans. That's the clearest audience for it: an online group willing to push past the first ten rounds together.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet