Analysis · Brotato

Brotato turns a potato and a between-wave shop into a smarter bullet heaven

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics called it smart and also quick to kill you

Digital Trends called Brotato a "smart evolution" of the Vampire Survivors formula. It credited the game with character builds that change more from run to run than the genre usually allows. Rock Paper Shotgun reviewed the game during early access. It enjoyed the retro feel, likening it to a "hit Flash game" from the Newgrounds era, but found that death came a little too easily. Those two reviews sum up most of the critical response. Brotato is a sharp, build-focused game in a busy genre, and its difficulty won't suit everyone.

The scores point the same way. An aggregate of seven critic reviews, dated September 30, 2025, lists the game at 76/100, while the same source's other figure is 57%. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.6 out of 10. Players liked it more than critics did. Steam users rated it "overwhelmingly positive", and it was one of the most popular roguelites on Steam in 2022 and 2023.

A potato, a wave timer and a shop between fights

You control a potato from a top-down view. There are several to choose from, each with different starting attributes, and more become available as you keep playing. The goal is simple: defeat as many waves of enemies as you can before one of them finishes you off.

Shooting is automatic by default, so your job during a wave is mostly to stay alive. If you'd rather aim yourself, a setting lets you switch to manual aiming. Enemies drop materials, and between waves you spend those materials to upgrade your attributes and your weapons.

That shop is where a run is won or lost. The fighting tests your movement, but the choices you make between waves decide whether your potato can survive the next one.

Why critics stopped calling it a clone

TouchArcade admitted that Brotato first looks like a simple copy of Vampire Survivors. It went on to say that the roguelike elements and the extra strategy give the game an identity of its own. Screen Rant described the systems as addictive, quick and easy to pick up, with plenty of room to experiment with builds, and it put Brotato on its list of the best indie games of 2022.

The praise has the same source each time. In most bullet heaven games the upgrades come at you and you pick from what's offered. Brotato's shop asks you to plan, and the potatoes' different starting attributes give each run a different starting point. That makes it a better pick than its genre neighbors for anyone who likes theorycrafting more than spectacle.

The reaction was strong enough to show up in the numbers: more than a million copies sold as of September 2022, and a nomination for "Best Steam Deck Game" at the 2023 Steam Awards.

Where the criticism lands

Rock Paper Shotgun's complaint about easy deaths is the clearest knock against the game, and it comes with the design. If one weak shop decision can end a run a few waves later, some players will feel the game is unfair rather than demanding.

The critic scores also show some disagreement. A 76/100 next to a 57% from the same aggregator suggests that not every critic was won over, though the reception text available doesn't say which reviewers held back or why.

A few practical limits are worth knowing before you buy:

  • It's single-player only, with no co-op listed.
  • The listed platforms are Microsoft Windows and Nintendo Switch.
  • It's rated Everyone 10+, so younger players can join in despite the constant combat.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet