Analysis · Chivalry 2

Chivalry 2 makes 64-player sieges sing, but its deathmatch modes fall flat

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The best praise and the sharpest complaint

The strongest line on record comes from PC Gamer, which called Chivalry 2 "the best medieval combat game out there" and credited its mix of "high skill and low comedy". The sharpest complaint comes from Rock Paper Shotgun's Brendan Caldwell. He found the deathmatch modes lacking the big moments of the objective battles and said some were "underwhelmingly short".

Both points hold up, because they're about different parts of the game. The large objective battles are the reason to buy it. The smaller modes are extras that critics didn't rate as highly. Aggregate scores run from 79 to 84 out of 100. Metacritic lists the reception as "generally favorable", and OpenCritic reports that 85% of critics recommend it. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 8.2 out of 10.

Swordplay that rewards timing and punishes carelessness

The combat system is easy to learn. You have three basic attacks: a slash, an overhand slash and a stab. They can be chained together, and any of them can be charged into a slower heavy attack that deals more damage. On defense, you block, and a well-timed block can stagger an opponent or set up a counter or parry.

The skill comes from what surrounds those basics. Friendly fire is on, so a wild swing in a crowd can cut down a teammate. You can throw your weapon, but that leaves you unarmed. You can also pick up severed heads and limbs and use them as weapons. Leana Hafer at IGN described the result as a compromise between hack-and-slash fun and skill-based melee, and that's a fair summary of the design.

The arsenal includes war hammers, maces, long swords and battle axes, plus bows, crossbows and javelins for ranged fighters. You can find more weapons in caches around each map, and this is the first game in the series to let you fight on horseback. You can play in first-person or third-person view.

The objective battles are the main event

Team objective mode is where Chivalry 2 earned its reputation. Up to 64 players split into two factions, the blue-and-white Agatha Knights and the red-and-black Mason Order. One side attacks a castle while the other defends it. A later update added a third faction, the Tenosian Empire.

Each battle is split into timed phases, and each phase has its own goals. Depending on the map, the attackers might have to:

  • destroy a final objective,
  • escort a player-controlled duke to safety,
  • kill the enemy duke, or
  • eliminate every remaining defender.

If the attackers run out of time, the defenders win. On some maps, the top-scoring players get to become the duke, which comes with extra perks. That gives skilled players a reward that changes the match itself, beyond a spot on the scoreboard.

PCGamesN singled out the maps, comparing their design and scale to both "Hollywood blockbusters" and "Monty Python". Caldwell found that the classes support different playstyles. Together, those comments describe the main draw: large set-piece battles where both heroic and disastrous moments happen naturally.

Where the smaller modes fall short

The game also includes team deathmatch and a free-for-all deathmatch. These are the modes Caldwell criticized. Without phases or a castle to take, they lose the momentum that makes the siege battles memorable, and some matches end before anything builds.

Brawl mode, added on October 26, 2021, is a looser option. It's a free-for-all for up to 40 players that only allows improvised weapons such as a fish, a chair, bottles, a rolling pin, bread and a turkey leg. It suits the game's comic side, but it's a side dish, not a reason to buy.

Buy Chivalry 2 for the castle sieges. Treat everything else as a break between them.

A finished game with a long update history

Torn Banner Studios kept adding to the game well after launch. It received 10 major updates before "Regicide", which arrived on May 22, 2024 and was announced as the final major update. The game reached Steam on June 12, 2022, after launching on the Epic Games Store on PC, and joined Xbox Game Pass on October 4, 2022. It runs on Windows, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One and Xbox Series X and Series S.

Torn Banner announced one million copies sold by August 18, 2021, and the Steam release added another 300,000 within 10 days. Since it's multiplayer only, how much you enjoy it depends on finding full servers, and those sales are a good sign for that. It's rated Mature 17+, and the severed limbs you can pick up and swing are a good indication of why.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet