Analysis · Clicker Heroes

Clicker Heroes built on Cloudstone's art and opened Steam to idle games

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A spinoff that reused Cloudstone's art

Clicker Heroes began as a side project. Playsaurus, an American independent studio, spun it off from its earlier game Cloudstone and reused many of that game's graphics. What Playsaurus built on top of that borrowed art is what carried the game across platforms: browsers in 2014, mobile devices in 2015, Windows and macOS, then Xbox One and PlayStation 4 in 2017.

That reuse explains a lot about the game. The art is there to support the numbers, and the studio spent its effort on the systems. Clicker Heroes is an idle game, and nearly every part of it serves one goal: making the numbers go up whether you are watching or not.

Your clicks matter less the longer you play

At the start, you click a monster until it dies and drops gold. You spend that gold to hire and upgrade heroes, and the heroes attack on their own, which adds to your damage per second. Soon the heroes are doing most of the work, and the game keeps running without you.

The structure stays simple:

  • Kill 10 monsters to clear a level.
  • From level 5, every fifth level is a boss level with a timer, and you only need one kill to move on.
  • Between levels 100 and 1,000, the boss of every hundredth zone is a "centurion" that drops Hero Souls.
  • After level 100, any boss has a 25% chance of being "primal", and primal bosses give far more Hero Souls later on.

The boss timers are the only real pressure in the game. If your damage can't beat the clock, you're stuck until you build more, and that wait is the wall critics kept hitting.

Ascension is what keeps players coming back

The real goal is Hero Souls, and you only collect them by giving up your progress. Ascension wipes your hero upgrades and sends you back to the first level. In return you get Hero Souls, which buy Ancients, permanent helpers whose bonuses depend on which one you pick.

This is the game's smartest idea. Each run goes faster than the last, so a reset feels like a reward rather than a punishment. It also makes the game very long, which suits players who like slow, steady gains and frustrates anyone who wants it to end.

Critics called it addictive, then scored it 57

Early writing on the game was warm. Kotaku's Nathan Grayson called it a "perfect office space distraction". Eurogamer's Christian Donlan described it as his gaming secret and talked about how hard it was to stop. Forbes writer Paul Tassi suggested it could become the top mobile game of 2015 if it caught on there.

The scored reviews were cooler. Sammy Barker of Push Square gave it 5/10, and his summary is the clearest warning on record:

"Too many brickwalls [sic] prevent Clicker Heroes from reaching the highs of AdVenture Capitalist, but this is still a frighteningly addictive incremental title." (Push Square)

A critic aggregate dated March 19, 2017, the year the console versions arrived, counts three reviews and lands at 57/100. The critic average of 5.7, calculated from those critic scores, matches it. The pattern is consistent: critics found Clicker Heroes compulsive, but compulsive isn't the same as good.

Its biggest effect was on other games

Whatever its scores, Clicker Heroes changed what showed up on Steam. Its popularity there led other incremental games to release on the platform, and it helped inspire The Longing. It also won Game of the Year on Armor Games, which shows it found its audience in the browser first.

It's rated Everyone 10+ and plays as a single-player game. The format suits short visits: check in, spend your gold, ascend when the gains slow down, and close it again.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet