Analysis · Code Vein

Code Vein borrows from Dark Souls, adds anime weirdness, and splits critics

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Delightful to some critics, a slog to others

The warmest line from critics came from Hardcore Gamer, which called Code Vein "surprisingly delightful." The harshest came from Game Informer's Daniel Tack, who found it weighed down by "stale scenery, boring bosses" and a lot of tiresome walking between them. Both views hold up, and that tension runs through almost every review of the game.

Critic aggregates put it at 73 out of 100 on Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Windows, each based on 35 reviews. Famitsu gave it 32/40. The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.5 out of 10. That's a respectable number for a game that critics loved and hated in equal measure.

Dark Souls structure with God Eater 3 animation

Code Vein is a third-person action RPG set in a post-apocalyptic world. Its play was modeled on the Dark Souls series, and its animation follows God Eater 3, whose developers worked on it. Bandai Namco Studios and Shift made it on Unreal Engine 4, and it supports single-player, co-op and multiplayer modes. It's rated Mature 17+.

Critics praised the ways it broke from that formula. IGN singled out how easily you can switch classes and experiment on the fly, and liked the game's willingness to mix things up and get "a little weird." Game Informer agreed there were "some nice ideas" in the design. It just felt those ideas never changed how the game really plays.

IGN pitched it at players after a fresh take on a familiar kind of challenge who can love and hate a game's quirks at the same moment.

Where the design wears thin

The criticism points at the parts that fill most of your time. Game Informer named three problems:

  • environments that repeat and look tired;
  • bosses that didn't hold its interest;
  • long stretches of walking between them.

IGN's main complaint was the AI partner. At times its uneven behavior made it more trouble than help. Since the partner is one of the game's signature additions to the Dark Souls template, that's a real knock. Hardcore Gamer liked the game overall but still listed problems with its story, combat, difficulty, visuals and world. That's a long list from its warmest critic.

The pattern is clear. The new systems drew most of the praise, while the basic loop of exploring and fighting drew most of the complaints.

A story critics enjoyed and argued with

Opinions on the story were as split as everything else. Electronic Gaming Monthly enjoyed its "utter ridiculousness" but said the deeper story underneath was hard to appreciate. GamesRadar+ liked the themes and found the characters "endearing." It called the Vestige segments, which you have to sit through to learn their backstories, cumbersome.

Other critics were harsher. VideoGamer.com felt the plot didn't hang together and called the dialogue and cutscenes weakly presented. Anime Feminist writer Tessie Alina Corwin criticized how the game treats its women: every important female character either starts out passive or ends up that way next to the men. If story matters to you, expect a big, earnest plot that critics found easy to enjoy in pieces and hard to take seriously as a whole.

Players stuck with it anyway. It debuted at number two on Japan's all-format sales chart with 60,843 copies in its first week, passed 3 million copies worldwide by March 2023, and got a sequel, Code Vein II, in 2026.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet