Company of Heroes 2 takes squad tactics to the Eastern Front, and draws fire
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A sequel built to show more of the war
Company of Heroes 2 rests on one idea, which director Quinn Duffy summed up himself: the sequel is "painted on a broader canvas." The 2006 original stayed close to a small group of soldiers. This game moves the series to the Eastern Front and mostly puts you in charge of the Soviet Red Army, from Operation Barbarossa to the Battle of Berlin.
Every other part of the game can be judged against that idea. Does the wider view change how a match plays? Does it change what a match means? Critics mostly said yes to the first. The second is where the trouble started.
Territory pays for the war
The broader canvas shows up first in the economy. You don't send soldiers out to gather supplies. You hold zones. A flagged point is yours when your units are inside its zone and no enemy units are there. Points produce munitions and fuel, and most armies can build caches on them to raise that income. Some points pay more of one resource but can't take a cache.
The catch is the supply line. A captured point only pays out if an unbroken chain of your territory connects it to your headquarters. If the enemy takes ground in the middle, your outlying points are cut off and your income drops. Manpower, which pays for ordinary units, also comes in more slowly as your army grows.
- Spreading out speeds up your income and the size of your army.
- Spreading too thin gives the other side a gap to cut.
- A large army costs more to keep growing.
This is the wider view at the scale of a single match. Every capture counts toward a front line, and that front line decides how much you can afford next.
Cover that burns and walls that give way
The buildings get the same treatment. Units can move into a civilian building and hold it as a strongpoint. Artillery, flamethrowers and grenades can force them out. The first game's building damage is back and goes further: a wooden building set on fire keeps burning until nothing is left, and tanks and light vehicles can drive straight into walls.
Each faction builds up differently. The Soviets work from a Regimental Field Headquarters that trains conscripts and field engineers. They have their own versions of the original's barracks, support and armor buildings, plus a field hospital for badly wounded soldiers. The Wehrmacht's Kampfgruppe Headquarters trains pioneers and MG42 Heavy Machine Gun teams, and you advance it through battle phases to gain access to stronger units and structures.
Huge, powerful and "a little bit broken"
Critics were positive but not unanimous. PC Gamer scored it 80 and compared the game to the USSR it depicts: big and strong, but "just a little bit broken." IGN gave it 8.4 and said it repeats many of the original's feats, though it reads more like a large expansion than a true successor. PC World gave it three and a half out of five.
The aggregate scores spread out the same way. One aggregate of eight reviews of the Windows version sits at 86/100. A wider one, counting 29 reviews, lands at 71/100. A third outlet's 7/10 is dated July 3, 2013. Taken together they produce a critic average of 7.9, which is calculated from critic scores rather than our own rating.
A wider view of the war, built mostly from the first game's parts.
Where the wider view drew fire
The broader canvas also brought scrutiny the first game avoided. Critics and historians questioned how accurately the game portrays the Eastern Front. In Russia and other post-Soviet states, many players and critics found it offensive because it shows Red Army commanders as cruel and willing to waste their own soldiers. After a video by the Russian blogger BadComedian, thousands of people signed a Change.org petition asking Steam to block the game in CIS countries. The Russian publisher 1C-Softclub stopped distributing it on 26 July 2013, and Sega said it was "taking this issue very seriously."
Writing for Polygon, Colin Campbell pointed to the strong feelings that the war still stirs up. If you play the campaign, expect a side of the war that people still dispute, not a neutral backdrop. The game is rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 18.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Company of Heroes 2 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2096469 wikidata.org