Critics never scored Rebirth below 87, and permadeath is the catch
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
High scores with almost no low end
The best number on record is 92%, an aggregate of 27 critic reviews dated May 15, 2022. The lowest is 87/100, from 26 reviews counted on January 4, 2016. A third aggregate, from 13 reviews, sits at 90/100. Only five points separate the warmest critical consensus from the coolest, and even the coolest is a strong score. The critic average, computed from those aggregates, is 8.9 out of 10.
So the sharpest criticism isn't a critic's pan. It's built into the design. Rebirth is a roguelike with permadeath: when Isaac dies, the game is over and the run is gone. Critics gave high marks to a game that's happy to throw away your progress. Before you buy, decide whether you can live with that.
Every run is a new basement
Rebirth is a top-down 2D game. You play as the boy Isaac, or as one of a large cast of other characters you can earn, and fight your way down through the basement and beyond. The levels are procedurally generated from a random seed and split into self-contained rooms, each floor with at least one boss. A run ends when you beat one of several final bosses.
Two features soften the roguelike structure without removing it:
- You can save a run at any point and come back to it later.
- Map seeds can be shared, so friends can try the exact same dungeon layout.
There's a catch on the second one. Seeded runs don't earn achievements, which stops players from using a known easy seed to farm them. That's fair, but if you're chasing achievements, every run has to be a fresh roll of the dice.
Stacking items is what keeps runs fresh
The controls work like a twin-stick shooter. One set moves Isaac and the other fires tears, which act as bullets. Health is a row of hearts counted in halves. Some items refill hearts and others add new ones. Along the way you collect bombs to damage enemies and break obstacles, keys for doors and chests, and coins to spend in shops.
The items are where Rebirth gets its variety. They change speed, tear damage and range, and some add a helper that floats behind Isaac and fights alongside him. The rules for carrying them are simple:
- Passive items: unlimited, permanent, and their effects build on each other.
- Active items: one at a time, used when you choose, then spent or recharged by clearing rooms.
- Consumables: one at a time, mostly tarot cards or pills.
- Trinkets: one at a time, like passives but swappable.
Because passives stack without limit, some runs build into powerful combinations and others never do. Floors also hold special rooms, including treasure rooms, shops, mini-boss fights, arcades, vaults, planetariums and curse rooms, so each run takes a different route through the floor.
Co-op is thin until the expansion
Rebirth adds more items, monsters and room types than the original game had, including rooms that span several screens. It also supports a controller out of the box and lets a second local player drop in and out at any time.
That second player gets a lesser role, though. They control a follower with the same attributes as the main character, it costs the first player one heart, and it can't plant bombs or carry items. It's a way to bring a friend along, not to play as equals. The Repentance expansion fixes this with 4-player co-op in which every extra player controls a fully functional character. If co-op is the main reason you're buying, plan on getting the expansion too.
Getting hold of the game is easy. It's on almost every major platform, from Linux, Windows and macOS to PlayStation Vita, iOS, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X and Series S, and Nintendo Switch 2 as of November 2026. It's also among the most played games on Steam. It carries a Mature 17+ rating, so it isn't a pick for younger players.
Sources
- Wikipedia: The Binding of Isaac: Rebirth en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q16267631 wikidata.org