Crusader moved Stronghold to the desert and made farmland worth fighting for
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A sequel that changed the map more than the rules
Stronghold: Crusader came out on July 31, 2002, one year after Firefly Studios' original Stronghold. It's the second game in the series and a close relative of the first. The economy, the castle building and the sieges all work much the same way. The big change is the setting. The game leaves Britain for the Middle East during the Crusades, and that move reshapes how a match plays.
The publisher listings differ. The game was originally published by Gathering of Developers, and Take-Two Interactive is also listed as its publisher. It runs on Microsoft Windows and is rated Teen and PEGI 12.
Oasis grass turns food into the thing worth fighting over
In the desert, farms can only be built on oasis grass. That one rule matters more than any new unit. Fertile land is limited, so players compete for it, and the food economy turns into a territory fight from the first minutes.
Other resources sit around the map:
- Iron ore for weapons
- Quarries for stone
- Marshes for oil
Everything goes to a stockpile, and then you choose: sell it, or spend it on defense. The same goes for building an army. You can make weapons and pay a little gold to turn peasants into soldiers, or pay more gold to hire troops straight from the new mercenary post, which also sells Arabian units. The cheap way takes planning, and the expensive way buys speed. That's a real tradeoff, not a cosmetic one.
One smaller change has a reason behind it. Your units are now red instead of blue, to match the colors of the Knights Templar.
Skirmish mode and a 50-level trail
The first Stronghold leaned on a linear campaign. Crusader adds a single-player skirmish mode, so you can set up custom battles against AI opponents. For a strategy game, that's the addition that keeps it worth replaying, because you're no longer limited to scripted missions.
There's still structured content:
- Historical chapters, mostly fictionalized, that start you with a fixed set of resources.
- A trail of 50 levels that get harder as you go. In each one you defend your kingdom and defeat one or more rival Kings.
- Three chickens at the start that let you skip a level you're stuck on.
The chickens are a small, smart idea. A difficulty ramp that long can stall players halfway, and a limited number of skips gets you past a bad matchup without making the climb meaningless.
The game was also released as Stronghold Warchest, which bundles the original Stronghold with an enhanced Crusader. That version adds more characters and a second trail of 30 levels, built the same way as the first 50 and also rising in difficulty.
What critics and sales charts said
Metacritic lists the game's reception as "generally favorable." The critic average of 8.6 out of 10 comes from a single critic's 86% for the PC game, so read it as one data point. There isn't much detailed criticism to weigh, either for or against.
The sales history tells you more. In Germany, it opened as September's fifth-best-selling full-price computer game, according to Media Control. It stayed in that chart's top 30 every month through June 2003 and was still 20th that month. In August it went straight to first place on the budget chart. By August 2004 it had spent 10 months in the budget top 20. It earned a Gold certification from the VUD, meaning at least 100,000 sales across Germany, Austria and Switzerland.
The US numbers were smaller. Edge reported at least 100,000 copies sold there, which trailed the first Stronghold's 220,000. Even so, a game that charts for that long is one people keep playing, and it's still among the most played on Steam.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Stronghold: Crusader en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q750086 wikidata.org