Datura's eerie forest earned praise, but critics found it short and confusing
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Praised for its mood, faulted for being short and confusing
The best thing critics said about Datura was about its atmosphere. IGN praised it, and Kotaku commended the game's originality. The worst thing came from the same Kotaku review, which called the experience confusing, unsatisfying and "ultimately fleeting". Both verdicts describe the same game: a strange, distinctive idea that doesn't hold together for long.
Metacritic grouped the reception as "mixed or average", and the critic aggregate of 10 reviews landed at 54/100. The critic average of 5.4 is computed from that figure. It isn't a separate judgment.
A patient, an ambulance and a forest
Datura is an adventure game from Plastic, a Polish studio that started as a demogroup, and Sony Computer Entertainment published it in 2012 for the PlayStation 3. It was the second time the two worked together, after Linger in Shadows.
The setup is spare. The game opens with the player as a patient in an ambulance, who then ends up, with no clear explanation, in a forest. From there the game is about exploration: moving through the woods and interacting with objects and with the other characters there.
Exploration and mood are the core of it. That focus explains why critics reached for words like "atmospheric" and "original" first.
Why the controls drew complaints
Datura supports two control schemes: the PlayStation Move motion controller or the standard DualShock 3 gamepad. Since interacting with objects and characters is most of what the game asks of the player, how that interaction feels matters a great deal.
Critics weren't happy with it. IGN singled out the clumsiness of the gameplay, and that's a serious problem for a game built on exploring and handling things. When the main action is awkward, the atmosphere has to carry everything, and the reviews suggest it couldn't carry the whole load.
Too short, and too vague to make up for it
Length was the most common complaint. IGN criticized how short the game is, GameSpot criticized it heavily, and Kotaku's "ultimately fleeting" makes the same point. Short games can work when every minute lands. Critics didn't think Datura managed that.
The story is the other weak spot. GameSpot faulted the lack of clarity in the plot, and Kotaku called the whole thing confusing. A vague, dreamlike story can be a deliberate choice, but critics found it combined badly with the short running time, leaving little to hold on to and not enough time to work it out.
Critics agreed on the mood and agreed on the problems: a short, clumsy, unclear game with an atmosphere worth noticing.
Who should still seek it out
The reviews are less split than the "mixed" label suggests. No critic in the record argued that Datura is long, clear or smooth to control. The praise is narrow but consistent: it feels different, and its forest has a real sense of place.
That makes it a curiosity more than a recommendation. It suits collectors of unusual PlayStation 3 exclusives and people interested in experimental motion-controller games. If you want a complete, satisfying adventure, critics gave little reason to expect one here.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Datura (video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q3702985 wikidata.org