Analysis · Kingdom Come: Deliverance II

Deliverance II is a stubborn medieval sim that critics mostly fell for

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The dissent was small, and the loudest argument wasn't about the game

Critics agreed on this game more than they disagreed. Its aggregate scores sit at 89 and 90 out of 100, OpenCritic counted 95% of critics recommending it, and PC Gamer named it Game of the Year. The clearest outlier came from Japan, where four critics at Famitsu gave it a combined 31 out of 40. That's a good score, but it's noticeably cooler than the Western consensus.

The record doesn't say what held Famitsu back, so it's best not to guess. What it does show is the quality that won the game its fans. PC Gamer's Joshua Wolens put it alongside other "system-heavy" games such as The Elder Scrolls III: Morrowind and called it a "ludicrously ambitious and peculiar thing" that pulls its ambition off. A game praised for being peculiar is a game some people won't take to, even if most critics loved it.

The loudest fight around the game came from players, not critics. Some players objected to expanded same-sex romance options for Henry and to the inclusion of a black character. Warhorse's PR manager, Tobias Stolz-Zwilling, said he was "fed up" with being pulled into the culture war and that the studio's aim was a historically accurate, immersive game. None of that showed up in the critic scores.

A world that remembers what Henry did

The systems critics praised are easiest to see in how other characters treat you. Missions can be solved in more than one way, and people and communities react to the choices you make. Those reactions then shape Henry's daily life and how he develops.

Talking your way through problems now draws on six skills. The first game's Oratory, Charisma and Intimidation are joined by Appearance, Coercion and Dominate. A character's lines change depending on whether your skill is high enough, so a conversation can open up or shut down based on how you've built Henry.

Crime gets the same detail. You can pick locks and pockets through minigames, poach, assault or murder. Witnesses can spot you, and people can even work out that you're the one behind their missing belongings. Stolen goods carry a red hand symbol in your inventory. If you're caught, your options include:

  • running from or fighting the guard;
  • paying a fine;
  • taking a caning, a branding or time in the pillory;
  • talking your way out with dialogue skills.

That range is what Wolens meant when he praised being able to play as a soldier, spy, gambler or blacksmith.

Fights and travel make you commit

Combat is played in first person. You pick the direction of each attack and block incoming blows, which leads into combos and counterattacks. Some of those moves are only learned through quests. The melee choices cover short swords, longswords, maces, axes, hammers and polearms, and one-handed weapons let you carry a shield. For range there are bows, crossbows and early firearms.

Small rules add friction. You can fight on horseback, but some ranged weapons have to be loaded before you mount and can't be reloaded in the saddle. Fast travel can be interrupted by meetings with friendly characters or enemies. With enemies, the game shows your percentage chance of avoiding the fight, and if you fail, the trip stops and the fight starts.

A post-release hardcore mode goes further. It removes fast travel, compass directions, your position on the map, and the health and stamina bars. It also asks you to pick debuffs, such as slower skill growth.

If those rules sound like the point, this is your game. If they sound like chores, the scores won't change that.

Bigger and polished at launch

The world is twice the size of the first game's, split into two large areas you can roam freely instead of one connected map. Reviewers said it ran well at release, with few obvious bugs or technical problems. That's notable for a game this dense. Brendan Lowry of Windows Central praised its "stunning naturalistic lighting" and what looked like "impossible draw distances."

Players showed up too. On Steam it topped the top-sellers list on release day and set its sixth straight concurrent-player record in six days, peaking at 256,206 players.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet