Dying Light's rooftop running and terrifying nights outshine its busywork
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Every street in Harran is a climbing route
Most of your time in Dying Light is spent moving. The game is played in first person in Harran, a city full of zombies, and you get around by climbing ledges, leaping from edges, sliding, jumping between roofs and riding zip lines. Later, a grappling hook lets you pull yourself up buildings and cross the city quickly.
Critics liked this more than anything else. USgamer's Mike Williams called the free running "a ton of fun". GameSpot's Kevin VanOrd said it "energizes moments of great tension" and described climbing tall structures as "an anxious exercise in precision". VentureBeat's Jeff Grubb praised the responsive controls.
Most fights use melee weapons. The game has more than 100 weapons and over 1500 variations through crafting and customization. Critics disagreed about how good the fighting is. VanOrd found it less satisfying than Techland's Dead Island. Destructoid's Chris Carter called it "deliberate" and an improvement on Dead Island. Game Informer's Brian Shea liked how brutal the close-up animations are, but thought the guns, which arrive in the second half of the game, felt less polished.
Night changes the whole game
During the day, the infected are slow, uninterested and easy to see. You can avoid them, set traps, rescue survivors and run to airdrops. Spikes, electrified fences and gas tanks let you use the city itself as a weapon.
At night, the infected get sharper senses. They sprint, hit harder, and jump and climb after you. Volatiles, the most dangerous enemies, only come out after dark. Your main defense is ultraviolet light, which slows them down. Your "survivor sense" shows where they are so you can stay out of sight.
This is the feature critics praised most often. Grubb called night play "exhilarating" and "truly terrifying". He also noted that the progression system rewards you for taking risks after dark. PC Gamer's Christopher Livingston called the difference between day and night "remarkable". If you're not ready for it, you can skip the night at a safehouse, which makes the danger something you choose.
The busywork wears thin
Weapons wear out with use. You can repair each one only a limited number of times or break it down for parts. Crafting needs both scavenged materials and a blueprint. Several critics wanted these systems trimmed. Williams thought they were there to make the game longer. Eurogamer's Dan Whitehead felt they stopped players from playing aggressively, and Carter wished Techland had cut the micromanagement and kept the focus on combat.
The missions drew sharper criticism. Polygon's Arthur Gies called many systems "clunky" and said the game pads its length by putting objectives as far apart as possible. Williams found the side missions better written than the main quests but said most were fetch quests. VanOrd compared the hero to an "errand boy". Critics also pointed out how much the game borrows from Skyrim, Assassin's Creed and Far Cry. Both VanOrd and Whitehead felt the zombies end up as a nuisance more than a threat.
A predictable story with good acting
You play Kyle Crane, an undercover agent sent into the quarantine zone. Most reviewers found the plot predictable. VanOrd said it "lumbers through one cliche after another" but is still "perfectly palatable". Williams called Crane "generic" but praised Roger Craig Smith's performance as him. Carter thought the characters were "contrived and boring", and Grubb said the story didn't make sense. Game Informer's Shea was the main exception: he found the story immersive and the characters easy to grow attached to.
Co-op is what keeps it going
Harran starts with the Slums and later opens up Old Town, reached through the sewers. Notes, journals and voicemail recordings add to the reasons to explore. Most of the game's staying power comes from its four-player co-op. Whitehead said the co-op challenges give players a reason to keep playing after the campaign. Shea said friends make the hardest parts "approachable", and IGN's Mikel Reparaz agreed the game is better with company.
Critics were split on the asymmetrical multiplayer mode. Whitehead called it "a blast" in a full lobby, and VanOrd liked how it stretched out the tension of the night. Reparaz warned that it gets unbalanced when the lobby isn't full, Livingston called it a half-baked version of Left 4 Dead, and Gies called it a "distraction". Critic aggregates range from 74/100 to 77/100, and those scores give Dying Light a critic average of 7.6.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Dying Light en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q13415292 wikidata.org