Analysis · eFootball

eFootball's pitch finally looks good, but the football still doesn't

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The one real argument was about the graphics

Critics disagreed most about how eFootball looks, which is odd for a game this badly reviewed. It launched on September 30, 2021, and critics and players called the graphics "atrocious." They also went after the laggy engine, the finicky controls and the thin content. With 92% negative reviews, it became the worst-rated game on Steam a day after launch.

Konami apologized and released a major 1.0 update on April 14, 2022. After it, IGN's Simon Cardy came down on the other side on looks: he praised the pitch, the player models and the stadium models. That's close to the only point where any critic changed their mind.

It didn't save the game. Cardy still gave it 4/10 and called it "hard to recommend" even though it costs nothing to play. An aggregate of 19 critic reviews, taken on April 27, 2022, puts it at 31/100. The critic average, worked out from those critic scores, is 3.1 out of 10.

What the 1.0 update left broken

The update was meant to fix many of the launch problems. Going by IGN's review afterward, the list of what stayed broken is longer than the list of what got better. Cardy's complaints included:

  • Skill moves and general play that behave inconsistently from one match to the next.
  • Opposing AI he described as dense and dull.
  • A pay to win model.
  • Too few game modes.
  • Flat matchday atmosphere and weak commentary.
  • A user interface that gets in the way.

The pattern is easy to read. The visuals improved, but the feel of a match didn't. A football game lives or dies on how a match feels. Cardy said the game was disappointing in so many areas that a "quick fix" was hard to imagine.

Two modes, and not much else

The game is built around two ways to play. Authentic Team puts you in charge of real teams. You can play offline against the AI, locally with friends, or online in events and friendly matches against another person.

Dream Team has you build your own club by hiring coaches and players. You choose its name, its uniform and its playing style, then take it into offline and online matches through the Events section.

Laid out like that, the critics' complaint about missing modes makes sense. There are two structures, and the Events section carries much of the online play for both. For a series that used to be a yearly full-price release, that's a small offer, even at no cost.

Who the split leaves room for

The presentation is the only thing that turned around, so the game suits someone who cares more about how a match looks than how it plays. If you mostly want handsome stadiums and player models, the post-update version gives you that, and it costs nothing to try. It's listed on PC, PlayStation 4 and 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Series S, Android and iOS.

Longtime fans of Pro Evolution Soccer (Winning Eleven in Japan) should be the most wary. eFootball is the revamped successor to that series, and the things fans would want from it are exactly what critics found lacking: steady controls, a smart opponent and a range of modes.

Parents should know two things. It's rated Everyone and PEGI 3, so the content is fine for kids. But IGN flagged the pay to win model, so set spending limits before handing it over.

The visuals got better after launch, but the play didn't. If you want a football game for the football, this isn't it.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet