Analysis · Europa Universalis IV

Europa Universalis IV rewards players who'll learn its systems the hard way

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics split over who can actually get in

The sharpest disagreement about Europa Universalis IV wasn't over whether it's deep. Critics agreed it is. They split over whether a newcomer can find a way in.

On one side, T. J. Hafer of PC Gamer called it an "engrossing simulation" that finds the common ground between the average Civilization V player and long-time grand strategy fans. That's a claim about reach: a game built for the hardcore that casual strategy players can still enjoy.

On the other side, the most common complaint was the tutorials. A game that asks you to juggle prestige, stability, ducats, manpower, legitimacy and three separate pools of monarch power needs to teach those well, and critics said it doesn't. Hafer's praise and the tutorial complaints can both be true. Once you understand the game, it's welcoming. Getting to that point takes work.

A map of Earth with no finish line

The game is an interactive map of the world split into provinces. Each province can add resources to your nation or become a source of unrest and rebellion. The earliest scenario starts on 11 November 1444, one day after the Christian defeat at Varna, and play can run until 3 January 1821. You can also start on any day in between.

There's no win condition. You might conquer by force, build a colonial empire or dominate trade. Your game ends only when your nation is annexed or the calendar runs out. The levers are wide:

  • Diplomacy: alliances, vassals and tributaries, and heading off defensive coalitions before they form.
  • Trade: the world is divided into trade nodes, and merchants collect the wealth that flows through them.
  • Religion: missionaries can convert your provinces, or you can allow religious freedom. Catholic nations can try to gain influence over the Papacy.
  • Institutions: ideas from feudalism to industrialization appear and spread, and your choices change where they start and how fast they move.

Critics credited the new systems like these, along with the improved graphics, as the main gains over Europa Universalis III.

Where the war game lost some reviewers

Combat happens on land and at sea and tracks morale, discipline, unit types, leader skill, terrain and supply lines. That's a lot of moving parts, and combat was one of the areas critics singled out for criticism. In a game where war is one of the main ways to grow, that complaint carries more weight than it would elsewhere.

Bugs were the other complaint. Nicholas Pellegatta noted them but expected later patches and expansions to fix many of the problems. Expansions didn't always help. When the 2021 expansion Leviathan launched, it was the worst-rated title on Steam, with only 7% positive user reviews, as players complained about bugs and features that seemed untested or unfinished.

The base game is well reviewed. Each expansion is its own purchase and should be judged on its own.

What the split says about who will like it

Read together, the praise and the complaints describe one kind of player. If you like systems that interact (a trade decision that weakens a rival, which sets up a war, which brings in a coalition), the depth critics praised is the reason to play. The game was named Best Strategy and Best Historical in Game Debate's 2013 awards and was nominated for Strategy/Simulation Game of the Year at the 17th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.

If you come from lighter 4X games and expect the game to teach you, the tutorial complaints matter more. Plan to learn from other players or by trial and error. Players who mainly want tactical battles should weigh the combat criticism, because the game's best features are its maps, its economy and its diplomacy.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet