Analysis · Everybody's Golf

Everybody's Golf treats the course as a place to hang out, not just play

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The idea is a course you can wander

Everybody's Golf treats a course as a place, not only a sequence of shots. You can free roam around its courses, drive a golf cart anywhere on them, and do it online alongside other players, using a golfer you create and customize yourself.

That idea sits on a long history. This is the twelfth game in the Everybody's Golf series and the follow-up to 2011's Everybody's Golf 6. Clap Hanz and Japan Studio developed it, Sony Interactive Entertainment published it for the PlayStation 4 in 2017, and in Japan it was released as New Everybody's Golf. The series came back with a different pitch: less a tee-to-green scorecard, more a hangout that happens to have flags in it.

The test for everything else critics and juries said is simple. Does it back up that pitch, or does the open course turn out to be decoration?

Critics liked it, though not all of them

Reception was solid. Metacritic called the reviews "generally favorable," and the aggregate scores sit close together:

  • 78/100 across 55 reviews
  • 77/100 across 11 reviews of the PlayStation 4 version
  • 72% of critics recommended it, according to OpenCritic

The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 7.8 out of 10.

Those numbers describe a game most reviewers were happy to recommend. They also leave room: by OpenCritic's count, a real minority of critics stopped short of a recommendation. That fits a game built around a mood. If strolling a fairway with friends appeals, the game is designed to deliver it. If you came for the strokes alone, the extra space may not move you.

Award juries saw the social game first

The accolades are where the central idea gets its strongest support. The game drew nominations on both sides of its identity.

On the sports side, it was up for Sports Game of the Year at the 21st Annual D.I.C.E. Awards and for Game, Franchise Sports at the National Academy of Video Game Trade Reviewers Awards. Game Informer's readers placed it fourth for Best Sports Game in their Best of 2017 awards.

On the social side, The Independent Game Developers' Association Awards 2018 nominated it for both Best Casual Game and Best Social Game. It also earned a nomination for PlayStation Game of the Year at the Golden Joystick Awards.

Nominations for Best Social Game and Best Casual Game are the clearest sign that the roamable, shared course registered as the point, not a side feature.

Note what the list holds, though: nominations and a fourth-place finish. The game was in the conversation across several categories, with no listed wins.

Where the idea runs thin

The open-course concept is easy to describe, and the published reception describes little else. There's no detail on how the swing feels, how many courses there are, how progression works or how long the game holds up once the novelty of driving a cart across a fairway wears off.

That gap matters for one kind of player. Someone who wants a simulation, with real courses and fine control over every shot, gets no evidence from critics that this game is aiming at them. The award categories (casual, social) suggest it isn't.

It's also a PlayStation 4 game only. If you don't own that console, this one isn't on the table.

For everyone else, the idea holds. Character creation, online play and free roaming all point the same way, and critics and juries rewarded the result. The one thing to remember: Everybody's Golf is at its best as somewhere to spend time with other people, and you should judge it on that.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet