F1 23 earned rare agreement from critics by changing how the cars drive
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The biggest disagreement is a few points
Critics barely split on F1 23. Metacritic called its reviews "generally favorable" and listed 84/100 from 13 reviews for each of the five platform versions, from PlayStation 4 and Xbox One up to PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X and Series S, and Microsoft Windows. A second aggregate, dated August 19, 2023, showed 85/100 from 58 reviews and 90% from 59. Every score falls between 84/100 and 90%, and none of the published praise comes with a dissent attached.
For a yearly licensed racer, that agreement says something. Series like this usually get marked down for being last year's game with new paint. Critics said the opposite here. Many called F1 23 an improvement over F1 22, which means the changes reached the part of the game you spend the most time in: the car on the track.
So the useful question is less whether critics liked it and more which of the things they liked matter to you.
What critics agreed on: the car behaves differently
Codemasters overhauled the driving physics, and the revised handling model drew the most consistent praise. Critics also credited the AI and the return of red flags, which the series hadn't included since F1 2014. Together those changes make a race weekend feel less scripted, because a crash can now stop a session and reshape the race.
The other driving-side changes are smaller but practical:
- A 35% race distance option, a middle ground between a sprint and a full-length race.
- A redesigned interface built to look much more like a current Formula One broadcast.
- The official 2023 Formula One and Formula 2 licences, plus the new Las Vegas Strip Circuit and Lusail International Circuit.
- Imola, Circuit Paul Ricard, Shanghai and the Algarve circuit kept on the menu, even though they weren't on the 2023 calendar.
If you care about how a car handles under braking and over a long stint, this is the reason to buy. The handling got the strongest praise, and it was the main reason critics put F1 23 ahead of F1 22.
Braking Point 2 surprised critics
The story mode, first introduced in F1 2021, returns as Braking Point 2. Critics praised its CGI graphics, characters, voice performances and plot, along with the new team at its center, Konnersport. Aiden Jackson is back as the protagonist and Devon Butler as the antagonist. Retired veteran Casper Akkerman returns as a mentor and later becomes Konnersport's Team Principal. Newcomers include Callie Mayer, Devon's sister, and their father Davidoff Butler. W Series driver Jamie Chadwick helped the developers with it.
One catch is that this is a sequel. Its rivalries pick up from F1 2021, so players who skipped that game will be joining a story partway through. Critics still rated it, which suggests it holds up on its own. Progress in the story also counts toward the Podium Pass, so it ties into the rest of the game.
F1 World is where your patience gets tested
Critics said little about F1 World, which expands on F1 22's F1 Life and ties ranked, esports, offline and online modes into one hub. That gap matters, because a lot of progression runs through it. You upgrade a car with new parts and hire team members, and you earn both through play. A Podium Pass, goals and compendiums hand out further rewards. Supercars and a virtual living space carry over from the previous game.
Upgrades can't be bought with microtransactions. The only shortcut is an XP boost paid for with PitCoin.
A new safety rating, similar to the ones in iRacing and later Gran Turismo games, applies online and in offline modes too. You can switch it off offline. For clean online racing it's a welcome rule. Solo players will probably want to turn it off.
Where the season moved on without it
The grid is a snapshot of early 2023. Nyck de Vries was in the game at launch and was then replaced by Daniel Ricciardo. Liam Lawson, who stood in for Ricciardo for five races after Ricciardo broke his hand at the Dutch Grand Prix, isn't included. Lusail still uses the old pit entry from the 2021 race. None of this changes how a race plays, but players who want a faithful replay of the season will notice.
The extras are generous. The Icons pack for building your own team now includes Nigel Mansell, Jamie Chadwick, Pastor Maldonado and Kamui Kobayashi. You can switch between a licensed soundtrack and an orchestral score by Ian Livingstone, and the music can even play through the trackside PA speakers.
Sources
- Wikipedia: F1 23 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q118136346 wikidata.org