Fable's Kinect spin-off has real heart but fights its own controls
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Made for Kinect owners who loved Fable's characters
This game was made for a specific player: someone with an Xbox 360 and a Kinect who came to the Fable series for its characters and humor more than its open world. It's an on-rails action role-playing game played in first person. It's also a standalone entry, separate from the main series, though it counts as the fifth Fable game. You don't roam a map or choose where to go. The path is set, and your hands do the work.
Lionhead Studios developed it and Microsoft Studios published it, with a first release on October 9, 2012. It was the first Fable built on Unreal Engine 3. It was also Lionhead's last game before the studio closed in 2016.
Spells are gestures, and the horse is half the game
Combat comes down to hand movements. Certain gestures cast certain spells, from electric bolts to magic shards. Beating enemies earns experience, which you spend on more health and stronger spells. That's the whole role-playing layer, and it's thin next to the earlier games.
A large part of the game happens with your horse, and that's where it does something the series hadn't tried before:
- Riding: you hold the reins in the air and guide the horse along the path.
- Care: you pet and brush it, and you treat it when it gets hurt.
- Cross-game links: playing Fable Heroes levels up your character here and adds extra items.
The horse care is easy to dismiss as a motion-control gimmick. But it gives you a companion to look after, and it ties in with what critics liked most about the story.
Where it delivers: characters worth caring about
Giant Bomb gave the warmest response, praising the characters, the humor and the emotional depth. Its reviewer wrote that players end up "genuinely feeling sorry" for certain characters when bad things happen to them. They also said the ending builds to what they expected to be one of the most poignant moments in any game that year.
That's the case for playing it. Fable always mixed silly jokes with sincere moments, and critics saw that balance survive here even with the switch to motion controls and a fixed route. If you remember Fable II or Fable III more for the people in them than for the property you bought, this game is aimed at you.
Where it doesn't: the controls get in the way
The strongest criticism came from Destructoid. Its reviewer granted that Lionhead clearly worked hard on the game, then argued that hard work didn't make it good. In their view, Kinect's limits meant the game was "boring when it works" and painful when it didn't.
When every spell, turn of the reins and stroke of the brush depends on a camera reading your arms, unreliable tracking hurts all of it at once.
The scores reflect the split. The game earned an aggregate of 61/100 on Metacritic, and its critic average of 6.3 out of 10 is computed from critic scores. Reviews were split between the story, which critics praised, and the controls, which they didn't. Even the best writing can't stop you from fighting the input.
The on-rails design is a second limit, separate from Kinect. If you loved the earlier games for wandering, choosing and shaping a hero over many hours, you won't find that here. You follow a set route, and progression comes down to upgrading health and spells.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Fable: The Journey en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q2074178 wikidata.org