Analysis · FIFA 23

FIFA 23 closes out the series with slick football and familiar frustrations

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for the player who buys FIFA every autumn

FIFA 23 is made for the football fan who already knows the series and wants one more season of it. It's the 30th and final entry in the FIFA series developed by EA Sports. EA Vancouver and EA Romania built it on the Frostbite engine, and it came out worldwide on September 30, 2022, for Windows, PlayStation 4, PlayStation 5, Xbox One, Xbox Series X and Series S, Nintendo Switch and Stadia.

You can play it alone, in co-op or online against other people. It's rated Everyone and PEGI 3, so it suits a family living room as well as a group of friends.

For that returning fan, critics mostly agreed that the football is in good shape. The reviews keep asking whether a good match engine is enough when so much around it feels like last year.

Where it delivers: the match itself

Critics praised what happens on the pitch. Game Informer called it "flashy, fun to play" and pointed to how many modes it offers. IGN gave it 7/10 and described its football as "slick and dramatic", a fitting send-off for the name. Even Ben Wilson at GamesRadar+, who wrote one of the tougher reviews, said the series bowed out on a high.

The scores back that up. Metacritic summed up the reception as "generally favorable". Aggregate scores for the main console and PC versions landed between 75 and 77 out of 100, and one outlet gave it 8/10 on launch day. The critic average, calculated from those critic numbers, is 7.6 out of 10.

Awards voters noticed it too. It was nominated for Multiplayer at the 19th British Academy Games Awards, and for Sports Game of the Year and Online Game of the Year at the 26th Annual D.I.C.E. Awards.

Where it falls short: money, control and repetition

Critics agreed just as much about the problems:

  • Pay-to-win. GamesRadar+ criticized the game's pay-to-win elements. That hits hardest for the online players the game works hardest to keep.
  • Control. The same review described moments where "player control felt sabotaged". That's a serious complaint about a game that stands or falls on how it plays.
  • Sameness. Game Informer said it was too much like earlier entries. IGN wrote that "familiar frustrations abound" and that the game still doesn't give some of its most popular modes enough attention.

Support was also thinner than the average scores make it look. OpenCritic found that 61% of critics recommended it, so roughly four in 10 didn't.

The Switch version is the one to avoid

The Nintendo Switch release is the big exception to the favorable reviews. Critics widely panned it, mostly because EA added no significant improvements over earlier versions on that console.

So a Switch owner who pays full price gets the least updated version of a game that critics already said changed too little. On that console it's an easy skip.

Whether to buy it depends on what you already own

If you've skipped the last few entries, the gap will make the familiar parts feel fresher. The match play critics praised is the main reason to come back.

If you played FIFA 22 a lot, the record points to a smaller step. You get better-looking football with the same annoyances and the same pressure to spend money in the online modes. At a discount, that's an easier trade to accept.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet