Analysis · Final Fantasy Legend II

Final Fantasy Legend II fixes the first game and keeps its strange heart

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

A sequel built to beat its predecessor

The game is built on one idea: take the first Legend game and make it better. Square kept most of the original's structure and changed what didn't work. Critics mostly judged it on whether that paid off, and nearly all of them said it did.

RPGFan's Patrick Gann, writing in 2000, called it the best of the Legend games and credited it with improving on the first game's systems while giving players more variety in how they play and where they go. Dexter Sy of IGN named it the best of the series' Game Boy titles. Years later, Jordan Rudek of Nintendo World Report reached the same verdict on mechanics, ranking it above the original.

When three critics writing decades apart reach the same ranking, the ranking is probably right.

The systems are odd on purpose, and mostly better for it

You lead a party of four, and monsters can join alongside humans. Battles are turn-based, with attacks, spells and items. What sets the game apart is how characters grow: there are no experience points. Instead, stats rise at random after each fight, and different character types improve in different ways.

The sequel adds its own touches on top of that base:

  • MAGI, magical stones you equip for new abilities and upgrades.
  • Fallen party members come back with one health point once a battle ends.
  • If the whole party falls, a character named Odin revives everyone, but you'll have to fight him later.
  • You can save anywhere outside combat.

Not every critic liked the growth system. Famitsu found the game easier and more enjoyable than the first, but missed the experience point system that was removed. That's the real trade-off here. Random stat gains make every fight feel like it could pay off, but they also take away the steady, predictable progress most RPG players expect.

More worlds, more reasons to explore

The second test of the core idea is scope, and this is where Gann's praise for variety holds up best. The party opens up a series of separate worlds one by one, starting with the First World. You walk between towns, castles and caves on a scaled-down world map, all shown from above, with water and mountains limiting where you can go.

NPCs point you toward the next step, and a journal collects those notes so they aren't lost. On a handheld meant to be played in short sessions, saving anywhere and keeping a written trail of clues fit the hardware well. Two magazine reviewers also liked the humor in the graphics and plot, though they added that underneath it the game was "vey much like all the other RPGs."

Better than the first game, but still old

Being the best Legend game doesn't free it from its era, and critics said so plainly. Sy wrote that it had aged compared with newer role-playing games. Reviewing the Switch port on its own, RPGamer's Elmon Dean Todd called it one of the Game Boy's best RPGs and also said it had aged poorly for modern tastes. Mitch Vogel of Nintendo Life went further, calling all three games in Collection of SaGa very simplistic by modern standards.

Random encounters break up travel, and the growth system can leave a character behind for no clear reason. These are the same habits the sequel inherited from the first game. It handles them better, but it doesn't remove them.

The DS remake made the same case again

The 2009 Nintendo DS remake from Square Enix stayed in Japan, and it's why the game sits among GameRaven's Nintendo DS exclusives. It repeated the original's move: keep the core and improve what's around it. Famitsu liked the new graphics and gameplay changes, and one reviewer pointed out how easy it was to play. RPGamer's Michael Baker praised the reworked progression system and new graphics while noting that the remake stays faithful to the original.

The remake also sold well in Japan, entering the top ten in its first two weeks with 124,000 units. For readers outside Japan, the Game Boy original has been easier to find since the 2020 Switch release and the 2021 ports to Android, iOS and Microsoft Windows.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet