Football Manager 2017 sharpens player growth but changes little from last year
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One critic saw a leap forward and another saw a standstill
The highest praise came from PC Gamer, which scored it 85/100 and called it a significant step up from previous versions. Trusted Reviews gave it 4.5 stars and called it "a very definite leap forward."
George Osborn of The Guardian made the opposite case. He noted that over the previous four years, each edition had changed how players build tactics, added in-game manager stats or brought new modes. His verdict on this one was blunt: "FM 2017 offers none of that."
Most critics sided with the praise. On Metacritic it scored 80 out of 100 from 47 critics, which counts as "generally favorable reviews." the critic average of 7.9 is calculated from critic aggregates, and it lands in the same place: a strong edition that doesn't reinvent anything.
You run the whole club, not just the starting eleven
This is the fourteenth game in the Football Manager series. Sports Interactive developed it and Sega published it, on Windows, macOS and Linux. The basic structure matches the rest of the series. You take charge of a football team as its manager, and you can choose a professional, semi-professional, amateur or international side.
The job covers several areas:
- signing players to contracts
- managing the club's finances
- giving team talks to the squad
Above you sit the club's AI owners and board, who judge your work on several factors. That pressure gives each season its stakes. The game is rated Everyone and has both single-player and multiplayer modes.
Squad building is where the improvements land
GameSpot gave it a 7/10. The review praised player development and smart transfers and called the game "easy to recommend" to a budding manager. Those two systems decide whether a squad gets better or falls apart over several seasons, so improvements there touch almost every part of the game.
This is the strongest argument for it. Osborn's complaint is about the lack of new headline features, and it's fair. But better transfers and player development shape a save more than a new mode would, even if they're harder to show in a feature list.
The tactics screen and the face scanner are the weak spots
The same GameSpot review that praised the transfers didn't enjoy the tactics interface. That complaint matters more than it sounds. Managers return to the tactics screen before nearly every match, so any friction there adds up over a season.
The new extras drew the harshest criticism. Osborn singled out the face scanner, which he described as purely cosmetic, and the added social media features. He called both "utterly inconsequential." None of the positive reviews named either feature as a reason to buy, which suggests they don't add much.
The improvements are in transfers and player growth. The new features are cosmetic.
Why the Steam rating is so much lower than the critics' scores
User reviews on Steam came out "Mostly Negative," far below the critics. The cause was a backlash from Chinese users protesting the lack of an official translation in their language, not the football itself.
For most readers, that rating says little about how the game plays. If you need the game in Chinese, though, the Steam rating reflects a real problem for you.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Football Manager 2017 en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q26933720 wikidata.org