Analysis · For the King

For the King turns tabletop dice rolls into a punishing co-op roguelike

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

The game that started a series

For the King is where IronOak Games' series begins. The Canadian studio put it on Steam in early access on February 28, 2017, and Curve Games published the full release on April 19, 2018. It came out on Windows, macOS, Linux and Nintendo Switch. A sequel, For the King II, followed on November 2, 2023.

So the useful question is what this first game took from the role-playing games before it and what it did differently. The short answer: it borrowed the dice and the permadeath, then changed who your heroes are and how much control the rolls leave you.

What it changed: tradespeople and visible odds

Most medieval role-playing games give you fighters and wizards. For the King gives you jobs. The blacksmith fills the usual warrior or tank role, and the scholar does the mage's work. Class sets your starting weapons and gear, plus your strengths and weaknesses across seven traits: strength, vitality, intelligence, awareness, talent, speed and luck.

Those traits are where the design is most distinct. Each one runs from 1 to 95 and is rarely below 40, and the number is your percent chance of pulling off an action tied to that trait. You don't roll a hidden die. You can see the odds before you act. Focus, a spendable resource that abilities and consumables refill, lets you push a roll your way when it counts.

The other change critics noticed was the party itself. Dom Reseigh-Lincoln of Nintendo Life singled out the freedom to split your characters across the map, saying it set the game apart from others in the genre.

What it kept: permadeath and a map that shifts

Under those changes sits a familiar roguelike frame. You pick an adventure, each with its own goal, and the map is randomly generated every time. It isn't random all the way down: each adventure keeps the same set of towns, enemies and terrain, so you learn its pieces even though the layout moves.

  • The map is built from hexagonal tiles, and you interact with whatever shares your tile.
  • Characters take turns moving, buying and selling weapons, armor and consumables.
  • Land movement depends on speed, and sea movement depends on talent.
  • Start a fight near your other heroes and they can join in, but so can nearby enemies.
  • Random events can hand out extra movement, items or healing.

It plays solo or co-op, with up to three heroes either way. Losing those heroes for good is where reviewers' praise came with conditions.

Where the dice turn against you

Visible odds don't make the outcome fair. Reseigh-Lincoln argued that swingy rolls, high difficulty and permadeath together could produce stretches where very little was in your hands. That is the main weakness critics found, and it comes straight from the system that makes the game distinctive.

Jonothan Bolding of PC Gamer also found it punishing at times. He judged the struggle worth it, though, because the end game felt rewarding. He enjoyed the art style too and found it funny in places. That light touch helps when a likely roll misses twice in a row.

Read the percentages as risk, not promises. The game's best moments and its worst ones both come from the same roll.

How it landed with critics

Metacritic rated reviews "generally favorable" on PC, Xbox One and Nintendo Switch, and "mixed or average" on PlayStation 4. As of April 4, 2020, the aggregate stood at 75/100 across 22 reviews, with a second published measure of 59%. The critic average of 7.5 out of 10 is calculated from those critic numbers, not given by a reviewer.

Together that describes a well-liked game with a sharp edge. Its new ideas, the professions, the percentage traits and the split party, are the reasons to play it. The same randomness that makes those ideas work is what some critics found hard to accept.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet