Forza Motorsport bets everything on the circuit, and mostly wins
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A racing game that only wants to race on circuits
GameSpot's Alessandro Barbosa summed up Forza Motorsport as "a resolutely focused circuit-racing game with real-world motorsport leanings." That focus explains the whole game. It explains what critics loved and most of what players complained about.
Turn 10 Studios built it as a reboot. It drops the numbers from the title and follows Forza Motorsport 7 as the eighth Motorsport game and the thirteenth entry in the wider Forza series. Xbox Game Studios released it on October 10, 2023, for Microsoft Windows and Xbox Series X and Series S. It has a single-player career and several online multiplayer modes. Each part of the game either backs up that narrow focus or shows what it cost.
The handling is where the focus pays off
The strongest praise went to how the cars feel on track. IGN's Luke Reilly called it "the best feeling game in the Motorsport franchise to date." Barbosa described it as "reliably accurate and satisfying on the tarmac" and said it looks and sounds stunning.
The technical features also serve the circuit rather than the showroom:
- real-time ray tracing on the track
- tire wear
- a dynamic time of day
- better-defined damage, with paint chipping and dirt buildup
- a fully procedural cloud system and volumetric fog
Tire wear and changing light belong in a game about long races on real-style tracks. Here the focus clearly works: the core act of driving got the attention, and critics noticed.
Car Points split the critics down the middle
The progression system borrows from role-playing games. As you race a car, you earn Car Points for that specific vehicle, and you spend them to change its top speed, acceleration and handling.
Reviewers disagreed sharply on it. Reilly disliked the new system. Barbosa called it the most "rewarding" progression in the franchise. Players, according to community response, sided more with Reilly.
Measured against the game's focus, the system makes sense. Because the points belong to each car, it rewards sticking with one machine and learning it, which suits a circuit racer. It suits people who like to hop between hundreds of cars much less, and the earlier Motorsport games had courted those players.
The cost is variety, and the launch made it worse
At launch the game had more than 500 vehicles, 800 upgrades and 20 newly built tracks, plus four DLC packs. Those numbers are smaller than earlier entries offered, and Barbosa said so plainly. He also felt the game lacked variety next to the Forza Horizon games, which is the downside of choosing a narrow focus.
Players were harsher than critics. Community complaints centered on three things: a large number of bugs, the progression system, and less content than previous games. On Steam, player reviews landed at "mostly negative", a long way from the critics' view.
Critics judged the driving. Players judged the whole package at launch, bugs included.
Online racing is the reason to stay
Reilly rated the online multiplayer modes the best in the series. Here the focus pays off again, since structured racing against other people suits a game built around circuits. He also missed split-screen multiplayer, so anyone hoping to race a friend on the same couch is out of luck.
Reilly framed the game as having the potential to become "a seriously rich racing destination over the coming years," provided Turn 10 kept adding free updates and post-launch content. That is a judgment about potential, not a finished product, and it fits the critic aggregates: an 85/100 across 28 reviews on each platform, an 84% recommendation rate on OpenCritic, and a critic average of 8.5 computed from those critic numbers.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Forza Motorsport (2023 video game) en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q107611729 wikidata.org