Gang Beasts is a ragdoll brawler that lives or dies on the people beside you
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The whole game rests on bodies that won't do what they're told
Gang Beasts is built on one idea: a fistfight between characters who can barely stay upright. The fighters are floppy, wiggly ragdolls, and every punch, kick and grab plays out through loose physics instead of tidy, scripted moves. Critics took to that idea quickly.
During its freeware alpha and its Steam Early Access run, The Guardian's Keith Stuart called it one of the "silliest beat-'em-ups ever made", Engadget's Jessica Conditt called it "a jolly good time", and Destructoid's Steve Hansen said its weirdness worked in its favor.
English studio Boneloaf Studios developed it and set it in the fictional Beef City. It's a party game first and a fighting game second. Every other part of it can be judged by one test: does it make the floppiness funnier, or does it only add more of it?
A knockout only sets up the real win
The fights follow a simple loop. You punch or kick an opponent until they're knocked out, then haul their limp body to one of the stage hazards and throw them over. That second step is where the core idea pays off, because moving a dead-weight ragdoll toward an edge is clumsy on purpose.
A knocked-down fighter isn't finished, either. Once they come back to consciousness they can fight back, so a near-win can turn into a scramble at the edge. This is the strongest case for the concept: the same floppy bodies that make the punches comic also make every finish uncertain.
The knockout is the setup. The throw is the win, and it can still go wrong.
The cost is precision. Anyone who wants clean inputs and readable combos will find the opposite here, since loose control is the point.
Twenty-two stages stretch the joke without changing it
At first release the game had eight multiplayer stages and costume customization. It now has 22 playable stages, plus modes beyond the standard brawl: Waves, Gang and Soccer. The hazardous stages matter more than their number suggests, because they're where every fight ends. A new hazard is a new way to lose.
The extra modes are harder to judge. Soccer played with ragdolls fits the core idea neatly: a sport about control, played by bodies that have none. But the critics' recorded comments are about the brawling, not the extra modes, so nothing shows the modes can carry the game alone.
It supports single-player and multiplayer, but its reputation rests on playing with other people. Both of its award nominations were for multiplayer: Excellence in Multiplayer at the 2018 SXSW Gaming Awards, and Multiplayer at the 14th British Academy Games Awards.
Why the praise cooled after early access
The early buzz didn't last into the full release. Reviews of the finished PC and PlayStation 4 versions were mixed. Metacritic lists 67/100 for the PlayStation 4 version, based on eight reviews, which it rates as "mixed or average". Other aggregates land close by: 60/100 from six reviews for each of the Switch, Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Windows versions, and 66/100 from 29 reviews. Another figure, based on 32 reviews, is much lower at 31%.
The critic average, computed from those critic aggregates, is 6.3 out of 10.
The record doesn't explain the drop in detail, so any reason is a guess. The likeliest one comes back to the core idea. A joke that delights in a free alpha gets judged harder once it's a finished product you pay for, and critics expect more than the joke. The game didn't stop being silly. Expectations went up.
Where it plays, and who should bring it out
Gang Beasts entered early access on PC in August 2014 and fully released on December 12, 2017 for Windows, macOS, Linux and PlayStation 4. An Xbox One version followed on March 27, 2019, and a Nintendo Switch version on October 13, 2021. Double Fine Presents published it until May 2020. Boneloaf Studios has published it since, with Skybound Games handling physical editions. It's rated Everyone 10+ and is one of the most played games on Steam.
That rating and the floppy slapstick make it a good fit for mixed-age groups, where winning doesn't take fighting-game skill. Nothing in the reviews suggests it offers much depth to someone playing alone.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Gang Beasts en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q18668465 wikidata.org