Going Commando outgrows the first Ratchet & Clank, then dares you to keep up
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Praised for doing everything better, faulted for its final stretch
The highest praise and the sharpest complaint both came from 1UP.com. It said Going Commando takes everything the first game did and "does better." It also warned that the closing levels turn into "wave after wave" of tough enemies meant to drain your ammo, followed by more waves after that.
Most critics landed on the praise. One aggregate puts the PlayStation 2 version at 90/100 across 46 reviews, and another at 91% across 73. Game Informer's Andy McNamara called it Insomniac's most compelling work so far. The open question is how much the difficulty spike, and a few weak side modes, should count against it.
Eighteen new weapons that change as you use them
The arsenal is the core of the game. Going Commando adds eighteen weapons, including the Blitz Gun, the Bouncer and the Lava Gun. Each one has a growth bar that fills as it defeats enemies. When the bar is full, the weapon upgrades, getting stronger and changing its look.
Ratchet levels up the same way. Defeating enemies fills an experience bar that adds nanotech health, up to a maximum of 80 health bubbles. Nanotech upgrades hidden in levels add more, and the new armor vendors sell up to four extra levels of protection.
- Bolts, the game's currency, come from defeated enemies and broken crates.
- Gadgets such as the Gravity Boots and Dynamo open up new areas, and the Swingshot returns from the first game.
- A save file from the original game gives you its "retro" weapons for free, though they never upgrade.
This steady growth is why critics read the game as a clear step up. Your firepower keeps changing well past the opening hours instead of leveling off early.
Harder than the first game, and critics disagreed on whether that's good
Going Commando is much harder than its predecessor, especially near the end. 1UP.com saw the late levels as a war of attrition against your ammo supply. GameSpy argued the extra challenge made the game more interesting than the original.
The split matters when deciding whether to play. If you want a relaxed platformer, the final levels may wear on you. If the first game felt too easy, critics suggest this is the fix. Once you finish, challenge mode raises the difficulty again but lets you keep the weapons and health you ended with, and it offers further weapon upgrades.
Arena fights got the praise, space battles got the blame
Away from the main planets in the Bogon Galaxy, the game includes four kinds of minigame: arena battles, spherical world battles, hoverbike races, and space races and battles. Critics didn't rate them equally.
Game Informer's Andrew Reiner praised the arena combat and the racing. GameSpy's Benjamin Turner said it was surprising how much fun "interstellar gladiator" could be. Some reviewers, though, felt the space combat was poorly done next to the rest of the game, and called the Giant Clank levels "brainless and boring."
The arenas are the side content worth seeking out. Expect the space battles and Giant Clank sections to be the weakest stretches.
Sharp jokes and standout visuals, with a little lazy reuse
GameSpot found the first game's humor intact. GameZone went further, ranking the cut-scenes among the funniest ever seen in a platformer. GamePro praised the pacing: the first game took about half its length to find its feet, but Going Commando reaches that point by the end of its second level.
Reviewers also praised the visuals, especially Ratchet's redesigned character model. GameSpy called it the most graphically impressive platformer on the market at the time. GameSpot liked the weapon graphics and sound effects but called the reused menu and mission screens "a little lazy." GameZone also praised the music and voice work.
Awards followed. IGN put it 11th on its 2007 list of the top 25 PS2 games and shared its November 2003 Game of the Month award between it and Final Fantasy X-2. The AIAS nominated it for Game of the Year and Console Game of the Year, along with awards for animation, art direction, character or story development and visual engineering.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Ratchet & Clank: Going Commando en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q5725706 wikidata.org