Golf With Your Friends lives or dies on who is holding the other clubs
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One critic called it excellent, another gave it a 4.9
The widest gap in this game's reviews is the gap between Screen Rant and Videochums.com. J. Brodie Shirey at Screen Rant gave it four stars out of five and called it "fun" and "colorful". He granted it has "minor faults" but was happy with the range of courses and game types.
A.J. Maciejewski at Videochums.com reviewed the Xbox One version and gave it 4.9 out of 10, the lowest score the game received. He thought it looked "promising" but called the play "extremely barebones". He also pointed to a lack of characters and to glitches.
The aggregates sit between the two. Metacritic files the game under "mixed or average" with a 63/100 across the Switch, Xbox One, PlayStation 4 and Windows versions, each built from five reviews. OpenCritic counted 27 reviews, and fewer than four in ten of those critics recommended it. The critic average from those critic aggregates is 6.5 out of 10.
Both reviews describe the same game
Read side by side, the two reviews don't really disagree about what the game is. Both describe a simple physics minigolf game with lots of courses and not much else. They disagree about whether that's enough.
Shirey judged it as a party game. For him the physics working "quite well for the most part" and the number of course types was the whole point. Maciejewski judged it as a game that should stand up by itself, and by that standard a thin feature list and no characters to speak of look like missing pieces.
That framing tells you most of what you need. If you want the game to carry the evening, you'll side with Videochums. If your friends are the entertainment and the game only has to stay out of the way, you'll side with Screen Rant.
What you get for the money
The numbers are the strongest part of the case for it:
- Up to 12 players in a match.
- 13 levels with 18 holes each, 234 holes in all.
- A level editor for building your own courses.
- Ball customization options.
- Featured maps based on The Escapists and Worms, two other Team17-published games.
A 12-player cap is generous for a minigolf game and is the main reason to choose this one over a solo golf puzzler. The level editor stretches the life of those 234 holes once a regular group has played through them.
It's rated Everyone 10+ and PEGI 7, so it works for mixed-age family groups as well as adult friends.
Where the glitch complaints matter
Blacklight Interactive, an Australian studio, built it in Unity. It spent a long time in early access on Steam, from January 30, 2016, before its full release on May 19, 2020 across Linux, macOS, Nintendo Switch, PlayStation 4, Windows and Xbox One. A Google Stadia version followed on April 14, 2022.
Shirey's "minor faults" and Maciejewski's glitches probably point at the same rough edges, and how much they bother you depends on the mood of the room. In a loud 12-player match, a ball doing something odd is a joke for the group. When you're playing a careful solo round, it's a reason to quit.
A game judged as a party game got four stars, and the same game judged as a standalone game got under five out of 10.
That split is a fair guide to buying it. The low score went to a critic who wanted depth. The high score went to one who wanted a good time with other people.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Golf With Your Friends en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q23303477 wikidata.org