Guns meet Dark Souls bosses in a co-op shooter that mostly works
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
Two guns, one melee weapon and a lot of dying
Every fight in Remnant: From the Ashes runs on the same kit: a main gun, a sidearm and a melee weapon. The guns range from machine guns and shotguns to hunting rifles and sniper rifles, and you can fit mods that add abilities, teleportation among them. The structure comes straight from the Dark Souls series. Enemies hit hard, bosses hit harder, and progress means learning a fight until you can beat it.
Critics thought that core worked. GameSpot called the combat against its "creative and challenging enemies" deeply satisfying. IGN said beating a boss that had beaten you for hours felt as good as the Dark Souls games that inspired it, though it also flagged frequent difficulty spikes. If you have no patience for walls you can only clear by repeating them, this isn't your game.
GameSpot's summary of the appeal: blasting enemies with weapons crafted from the remains of your latest boss kill is hard to do without "a wide smile on your face."
Death costs you time, not progress
Here Remnant breaks from the games it borrows from. Dying never takes away items or skill points. You go back to the last checkpoint, and the enemies waiting there can change in number or type each time.
That changes how a hard section feels. A failed attempt costs you only the walk back, and the shuffled enemies stop a retry from turning into rote memorization. It's a softer kind of punishment than the genre usually hands out. For players who bounced off Dark Souls because of what death took from them, that matters more than any single difficulty setting would.
A random world wrapped around a set story
The world is randomly generated, but the story follows a fixed path. Which enemies and bosses you meet depends on how your world rolled. That makes the game easy to replay, and it also explains its oddest co-op rule.
Up to three players can team up, and the difficulty scales to the size of the group. A player who joins someone else's game earns the same loot as the host. Back in their own world, though, they still have to play the story through themselves, because their world may hold different enemies and bosses. Expect to clear some content twice if you mostly play as a guest.
Critics still rated the co-op highly. IGN called it one of the most rewarding co-op experiences "in quite some time." GameSpot was cooler on the overall design and said "confusing" describes the game much of the time, especially where its borrowed ideas don't fit together.
The gear and the plot are where it sags
You upgrade weapons and armor with materials found in the world, and trait points raise your character's stats. It reads like a full loot game, but critics weren't impressed. IGN called the gear system "underwhelming" and said it sometimes takes the shine off a hard-won victory. GameSpot said the game fails to turn its combat into an engaging loot system or an interesting story.
The fair reading is that the reward loop between fights is thinner than the fights themselves. You come back for the bosses and the friends, not for the numbers on your armor or for the plot.
Scores, versions and staying power
Metacritic rated the game "generally favorable" on most platforms. The Nintendo Switch port, released in March 2023, rated "mixed or average" instead. Aggregate scores sit in a tight band:
- Most aggregates: 76 to 78 out of 100
- One later aggregate: 70%
- critic average: 7.7 out of 10, computed from those critic aggregates
For a 2019 game, it has held its audience well. It had sold over 3 million units by December 2021, and it's still among the most played games on Steam. The random worlds and three-player co-op account for much of that staying power. If you're picking a platform, the record points away from Switch.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Remnant: From the Ashes en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q66975659 wikidata.org