HAL Laboratory traded Poké Balls for a camera, and critics mostly loved it
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
A Pokémon spin-off from the studio behind Kirby
Pokémon Snap was one of the first Pokémon games made for a home console, and for many Pokémon it was their first appearance in real-time 3D. HAL Laboratory, the studio behind the Kirby games, developed it and Nintendo published it. It came out in Japan on March 21, 1999, in North America that July and in PAL regions in September 2000.
It's a side project, not a main entry. There's no battling, no collecting and no trainer to level up. The Pokémon stayed, and so did Professor Oak, who now grades your photos instead of handing out starters. Years later, IGN said the game "made the Pokémon world feel real" in a way the main games hadn't.
What changed: a camera instead of a Poké Ball
The game asks you to ride a vehicle called the Zero-One along a fixed track, seen in first person, and photograph whatever you pass. You get up to 60 pictures per visit. At the end of a course you choose your best shot of each Pokémon, and Professor Oak scores it on the Pokémon's size, its pose and how well it's framed.
Bonus points go to special poses, like a surfing Pikachu, and to shots with several of the same Pokémon in the frame. Good scores and a wide spread of species fill the Pokémon Report, and that's how you move forward. An Album Mark lets you save your favorite shots to an in-game album to look at later or show friends.
The rail shooter structure was the risky part. The Denver Post's David Thomas wrote that the idea should have "never worked" and still called it one of the most creative games on the market.
Seven courses that open up as you get more tools
There are only seven courses: Beach, Tunnel, Volcano, River, Cave, Valley and a special course called Rainbow Cloud. The game stretches them by giving you tools one at a time, and each new tool changes what an old course can show you:
- Pokémon food, shaped like apples, stuns Pokémon or draws them closer.
- Pester Balls knock Pokémon out or flush them from hiding.
- The Poké-Flute wakes, irritates or hatches Pokémon, and its three songs set off different dances.
- The Dash Engine lets the Zero-One speed up.
Going back to old courses turns up hidden Pokémon, other routes and better shots. Allgame's Scott Alan Marriott said that despite the few courses, the game has a "substantial amount of replay value." Boys' Life singled out the Pokémon's reactions as "always entertaining."
Where critics pushed back
The same two complaints come up again and again. The game is short, and it includes only 63 of the original 151 Pokémon. IGN's Matt Casamassina called it "addictive" but warned that devoted fans would be let down by the selection, and he raised the length again in later pieces.
Some critics thought its appeal was limited. GamePro and GameRevolution both called it great for fans and kids, and GameRevolution called it only a "decent diversion" for everyone else. The Detroit Free Press's Mike Floyd said it lacked the depth to be great, and Kotaku called it a "cash-in branded title."
The Virtual Console re-release got a mixed reception. Nintendo Life called it "super short" while still praising it as a relaxing break from other Pokémon games. RPGamer said it had "zero replayability," which flatly contradicts Allgame. Which side you land on mostly depends on whether replaying courses for better scores appeals to you.
Why it outlasted its flaws
At release it scored 77/100 on Metacritic. The critic average, calculated from the one critic score on file, is 7.8. It won Console Children's/Family Title of the Year at the 3rd Annual Interactive Achievement Awards. Famitsu praised its mood:
A "sense of peace," and "the feel of a safari or a theme park." (Famitsu)
The game kept coming up long after 1999. Critics compared Dead Rising's photography and Beyond Good & Evil to it, and game design books use it as an example of "aim & shoot" play. It returned on the Wii's Virtual Console, then the Wii U's, and on Nintendo Classics in June 2022, and the series continued with New Pokémon Snap in 2021.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Pokémon Snap en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q1705294 wikidata.org