Hotline Miami 2 trades tight rooms for sprawling levels and a split verdict
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
One hit ends you, and one button brings you back
Every chapter asks the same thing: clear every enemy in the building. You do it with melee and ranged attacks, by slamming doors into people and with finishing moves on anyone you knock down. The catch is that a single hit kills you, just as it kills them.
That would be harsh if dying cost much. It doesn't. A quick restart drops you back at the start of the stage, so each death becomes a lesson about where a guard stands or which door to open first. New enemy types keep the lessons coming. Guard dogs can't be hurt by unarmed attacks, and some heavy thugs go down only to bullets.
Enemy behavior is uneven. Some react at once, and some don't notice a body hitting the floor right in front of them. Whether that reads as chaos or sloppiness depends on how much you like the series' arcade roots.
Bigger levels came with fewer choices
The stages are built from large, open rooms with many ways for enemies to reach you. Most chapters also hand you a different character, each with their own abilities. One can dodge, and another can beat opponents without killing them. Some get to choose weapons or masks, and each mask changes how they play.
This is where critics split. Alex Carlson of Hardcore Gamer thought the larger maps made the level design feel more realistic and varied. Steven Burns of VideoGamer saw a case of "bigger is better": less freedom, and success that depended too much on which character the level gave you.
Chloi Rad of IGN liked those characters, calling the pacifist one a "shocking twist" for the series, and framed the tighter rules as a trade of some arcade feel for a bigger story. Maddy Myers of Paste was far harsher, calling the game a "glorified DLC pack" of new levels. The design changes were contentious with fans too. In a 2022 interview with Noclip, the developers said they were harassed after release because of them.
A story told from too many seats
The plot runs before, during and after the first game, tracing the background and fallout of Jacket's massacres of the Russian mafia in Miami. You see it through several characters in different parts of the United States, and it's far more elaborate than the original's.
Burns and Rad both praised it, Burns for the world Dennaton built and Rad for how different the characters' motives are. Dave Cook of Vice called it a "smart story" that many people missed, and liked the ending. Chris Thurster of PC Gamer and Tony Coles of Eurogamer weren't sure the series needed this much lore at all. Alec Meer of Rock Paper Shotgun found it hard to follow, calling it a "disordered jumble" of scribbles.
The constant character swapping is the likely sticking point. If you want a puzzle to piece together, it suits you. If you want to know why you're in each room, it may not.
The soundtrack is the part nobody argued about
Critics agreed that the music matched the first game's and was among the best things here. Chris Carter of Destructoid counted it among his favorite game soundtracks. Thurster and Burns both pointed to how well the music fits the action, and Thurster singled out "Roller Mobster." Writing for VG247 in 2018, Caty McCarthy called the use of "You Are the Blood" in the ending sequence harrowing.
A scene you should know about, and a reason to keep playing
The opening tutorial ends with a cutscene showing an attempted sexual assault, which is then revealed to be a film shoot inside the game's world. Critics widely faulted it. Burns called it a "grave mistake" that existed for shock value, and Thurster called it "artless and alienating." Astrid Budgor of Kill Screen was the exception, reading it as setting up the game's theme of reality versus fiction. The game includes options to cut or skip the scene. It's also why the game was refused classification in Australia, where it still can't be sold.
The game lasts beyond the campaign in two ways:
- Hard Mode opens up after you finish, for any level where you earned a C+ or better. Enemies are tougher and lock-on is removed.
- The level editor in the Steam version lets players build levels, cutscenes and dialogue, and share full custom campaigns on Steam Workshop.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q16267674 wikidata.org