Analysis · Inscryption

Inscryption's cabin won critics over, and its later acts split them

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Critics agreed on the first act and split over the rest

The biggest argument about Inscryption isn't about its card rules. It's about the game's choice to stop being the game it starts as. The first act puts you at a table in a dim cabin, playing a roguelike deck-builder against a gamemaster named Leshy, and critics praised it almost without exception. Then the game changes shape twice, and that's where reviewers parted ways.

PC Gamer's Jody Macgregor called the opening hours "an eerie delight" but said the feeling "fades long before it ends". Destructoid liked the art and the horror but said nothing in the later chapters held it as firmly as the first. On the other side, Polygon named Inscryption its best game of 2021. It also won Game of the Year at the 22nd Game Developers Choice Awards and the Seumas McNally Grand Prize at the 2022 Independent Games Festival. It was the first game to win both top prizes.

A card game played on a scale of teeth

The core rules are simple and they never change. Cards go onto a 3x4 grid. You play into the bottom row, while your opponent places cards in the top row a turn early, so you can see what's coming before it slides into the middle. Each card hits whatever sits in its column. If nothing blocks it, the damage goes straight to the other player.

That damage lands as teeth on a weighing scale, and you win by tipping it five teeth in your favor. Rock Paper Shotgun singled this out, saying the back-and-forth of losing and gaining momentum makes it "a compelling twist". It means a losing game can swing back in one aggressive turn.

Costs give the decks their character. Leshy's cards need a blood sacrifice from cards already on the board. Grimora's need bones, earned when cards die or are sacrificed. Sigils add abilities such as flying over a blocker or hitting several columns at once.

Why the cabin works so well

In the first act, each run crosses four randomly generated maps where you choose a path through card battles, deck changes and one-use items. Lose twice on a map, or once to a boss, and Leshy turns you into a death card with his camera. That card can turn up in later runs, so even a loss feeds the game.

Between fights you can get up from the table and search the cabin, solving escape-room puzzles that hint at something larger. Eurogamer compared the look to "a cursed reincarnation" of a '90s floppy-disc adventure. This mix of deck-building, puzzles and dread is the part nobody complained about.

What the later acts change, and who that suits

Act two drops the cabin for pixel-art, top-down role-playing in the style of Pokémon. Act three widens the board to 3x5. The other card makers come into play: P03's cards run on energy that refills and grows each turn, and Magnificus's need a gem on the board to stay in play.

Whether that works for you depends on why you came. If the deck-building loop is the draw, the later acts can feel like a detour from the best version of the game, which is the core of the complaints from PC Gamer and Destructoid. Destructoid admitted the changes may have kept things from going stale. If the mystery is the draw, the shifts are the payoff, and that reading is what took the game to Game of the Year.

Go in knowing as little as you can. Most of the praise rests on surprise.

It's rated Mature 17+ and PEGI 16, and the horror is part of what critics praised, so it isn't a pick for younger players.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet