Legendary Edition rebuilds the first Mass Effect and keeps the trilogy whole
Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.
The 2007 game got the biggest rework
The biggest changes are to how the first game plays from moment to moment. BioWare reworked its combat mechanics, vehicle handling and loading times, along with its graphics. No other game in the collection got changes this deep.
Most reviewers thought it worked. Alyssa Mercante of GamesRadar+ said the changes made the first game feel more modern and closer to its sequels without losing its original charm. Not everyone agreed. Some critics thought the gameplay updates didn't go far enough, so the oldest game still plays like the oldest game, just with fewer rough edges.
The middle game had smaller but noticeable changes. Writing for Destructoid, Eric Van Allen praised the adjustments to Mass Effect 2's morality system, saying they made it feel less unforgiving. That matters in a series where the choices you make carry forward.
Three games, one story, expansions included
Legendary Edition collects Mass Effect (2007), Mass Effect 2 (2010) and Mass Effect 3 (2012) in one release. It's a single-player package, and its main appeal is playing the whole saga in order with the add-on content already there.
Critics disagreed about how well that extra content fits:
- Robert Ramsey of Push Square said the expansions missing from the base version of Mass Effect 3 made it a meaningfully better game.
- Kimberly Wallace of Game Informer welcomed the chance to play the story in its most complete form, with all DLC included.
- Jordan Ramée of GameSpot criticized the collection for not fitting the DLC well into each game's story.
All three agree the content is there and worth having. They disagree about whether it feels like part of the story or like extra missions added on.
A visual overhaul that split the purists
The graphics drew the strongest praise. Shubhankar Parijat of GamingBolt called it one of the most impressive remasters he had seen and credited the work on assets, environments, lighting and character models. Dan Stapleton of IGN said Mass Effect 2 now looked close to a modern release, with one clear exception: its facial animations.
The pushback on the first game came from two directions. Some critics felt its new look went too far and buried the mood and tone of the original. Others, as noted above, wanted the gameplay pushed further. The remaster changed the oldest game's look a lot and its systems only somewhat, and each half of that choice drew complaints.
The first game changed the most, and that's where most of the praise and the complaints both landed.
Where it stands with critics and players
Critics were consistently positive. OpenCritic reports that 96% of 122 critic reviews recommend the game. One aggregate puts the Xbox One version at 90/100 across nine reviews, the PlayStation 4 version at 89/100 and the Windows version at 85/100. The critic average of 8.7, computed from those critic aggregates, sits in the same range.
Players showed up too. In its release week, the Windows version passed 59,000 concurrent players on Steam, the highest count to that point for a BioWare title.
Jhaan Elker of The Washington Post recommended it to both longtime fans and newcomers, with one caveat: some players may still prefer the original games with mods. Thomas Morgan of Eurogamer called it a perfect jumping on point for the series. If you're new to Mass Effect, start here. If you already have a modded setup of the originals, there's less reason to switch.
Sources
- Wikipedia: Mass Effect Legendary Edition en.wikipedia.org
- Wikidata: Q101246186 wikidata.org