Analysis · Lost Odyssey

Lost Odyssey's thousand years of dreams outshine its old-school battles

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Made for players who miss the classic turn-based RPG

Lost Odyssey is for players who grew up on Japanese role-playing games and want one that doesn't apologize for it. Mistwalker and feelplus built it around the old formula. You move a party across a world map between towns and fields, rest at inns, buy gear in shops, save at save points and fight monsters in random encounters. Later on, ocean-going ships open the world up for more exploring.

It launched on the Xbox 360 in Japan on December 6, 2007, and reached North America on February 12, 2008. It can also be bought from the Xbox digital store and played on Xbox One and Xbox Series consoles through backward compatibility, so the hardware it first shipped on isn't a barrier.

Critics mostly liked it. It holds a 78/100 on Metacritic, and Famitsu gave it 36/40, with all four of its reviewers scoring it a 9. The critic average, computed from 6 critic scores, is 7.9 out of 10.

The dream stories are where it delivers most

At inns you can read the "thousand years of dreams," a series of visual novel flashbacks written by Kiyoshi Shigematsu. Critics praised these sequences widely, including reviewers who didn't think much of the rest of the game.

RPGFan is the clearest example. It called the main story and gameplay "overused, uninspired, and stilted," yet ranked the memory sequences among the most "emotionally charged" storytelling in any RPG. GameSpot called the flashbacks "emotionally gripping."

GameTrailers singled out "a deeply moving story" as the thing that sets the game apart.

If you play role-playing games mainly for their writing, this is the strongest reason to pick up Lost Odyssey.

Combat keeps the old rules but adds timing and team building

Battles are turn-based, and the order of play depends on initiative and on how long each action takes. Items take effect right away and melee attacks land the same turn. Spells and special abilities can push your action back one or more turns, and getting hit can delay it further. You can cancel a queued action on a later turn.

Three systems add depth to that base:

  • Aim rings. As a character attacks, two rings appear on screen, and releasing the button at the right moment makes them overlap. A Perfect, Good or Bad rating sets how strong the ring's effect is, whether that's extra damage, draining HP or mana, a status ailment or a stolen item. You build rings from components and can combine them into better ones.
  • The wall. Up to five party members fight in a front line and a back line. The back line is protected by a defensive wall that depends on the front line's combined hit points, so the wall weakens as your front line takes hits.
  • Mortals and immortals. Mortals learn skills by leveling up. Immortals learn by linking with a mortal in the battle formation, then slot what they've learned into a limited number of skill slots, starting at three.

IGN said the rings, immortals and skill system gave the combat a fresh feel, and 1UP.com said the timed button press makes battles more engaging than you'd expect. Xbox Focus's Alex Yusupov went further and called the fights exhilarating.

Where it loses even willing players

Most critics who disagreed with Yusupov had the same complaint: the old-school design. Several found the turn-based combat dull and dated. The random battles were made worse by long load times, the issue reviewers raised most often. One fact softens that complaint. Some review copies apparently loaded more slowly than the retail version, and GameSpot updated its review on February 19, 2008, to say so, though it kept its original score. Reviewers also pointed out framerate problems.

The main plot divided critics more than anything else. GameSpot praised a "fascinating cast" and a "great plot," and Game Informer called it one of the most compelling stories on the Xbox 360. GameSpy called the main plot and characters "shamelessly derivative." GamePro found the central story weak, though it said many of the subplots carry real emotional weight. Xbox Focus, otherwise a fan, complained about the camera controls and the odd character design.

The one point nearly every critic agreed on was the look of the game: its graphics and high production values were acclaimed throughout. So the risk comes down to pacing. If random fights and waits between them wear you down, the strong presentation won't make up for it.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet