Analysis · Manor Lords

Manor Lords grows towns without grids but leaves them little to do

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

One developer and two million wishlists

Manor Lords comes from Grzegorz "Greg" Styczeń of Slavic Magic and is published by Hooded Horse. It went into early access on April 26, 2024, already the most-wishlisted game on Steam, with over two million wishlists. It isn't part of a series. That's an unusual amount of attention for a medieval city-builder from a single named developer, and the launch matched it: more than one million copies sold over the launch weekend and over three million by February 2025.

Critics were warmer about its ambition than about how much game there is so far. Aggregate scores landed at 74/100 for both the Xbox One and Windows versions across seven reviews, and at 71/100 across 12 reviews in another tally, which also gave a 50% figure across 14 reviews. The critic average, calculated from those critic aggregates, is 7.3 out of 10.

What it changed: towns that grow along the land

The big change is in how you lay a town out. Most city-builders give you a grid. Here, roads are almost always curved and houses go up without the fixed zoning you'd see in SimCity and Skylines games. The setting draws on late 14th-century Franconia, and the building rules copy how real medieval villages grew, shaped by trade routes and the lie of the land.

The economy goes deeper than the genre usually does. You juggle:

  • six types of taxation, plus tithes that affect how content your villagers are;
  • a yearly King's tax, imports and exports, and bandit raids;
  • soil exhaustion and deforestation if you push growth too fast;
  • seasons with their own demands, and buildings that need upkeep to keep working.

Critics pointed to the game's historical accuracy, though Styczeń has said gameplay sometimes won out over strict historical detail. You can also drop from the bird's-eye view into a third-person camera and walk your own streets, a small touch that suits a game about how a place looks as it grows.

What it kept from the strategy greats

Before release, Matt Jarvis of Rock Paper Shotgun compared parts of it to Total War, Crusader Kings and Age of Empires, calling it "hugely ambitious" and "filled with potential". The influences show in the warfare. In some modes you fight AI lords, push into new territory or face an expanding Baron. You can hire mercenaries, train and equip a personal retinue, or arm your villagers, then fight real-time battles where fatigue, weather and equipment all count. There's diplomacy too, using influence or threats on rival lords.

This is where critics were least convinced. Aleksa Stojković said combat was the part he liked doing least. IGN's Leana Hafer said there was no proper way to test the battles definitively. The war layer works, but it reads as a frame around the town rather than the reason to play.

If you only want the building, Rise to prosperity is the combat-free mode. The other four modes add varying amounts of fighting.

Where early access shows

The complaints were consistent: you run through the content quickly and there's no real goal to aim for. Specific points from reviewers:

  • IGN's Leana Hafer called it unfinished and pointed to the lack of endgame challenge.
  • Eurogamer's Robert Purchese missed any kind of story, including stories about the villagers you look after.
  • Mitch Gassner argued that with so many unfinished parts, it can't keep people playing for weeks.
  • Ravi Sinha wanted more policies, plus random events to break up long, dull waits.

None of these complaints say the systems are broken. They say there isn't enough of them yet. A town that grows well but never faces a serious test is a fair summary of the reception.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet