Analysis · MechWarrior Online

MechWarrior Online rewards patient mech pilots and leaves newcomers lost

Written from the published record (critics' reviews, the developer's documentation and the game's history), not a hands-on playthrough. How these are written.

Built for players who'd rather aim carefully than react fast

MechWarrior Online is a free-to-play multiplayer game for Windows, set in the BattleTech universe. Players pilot battlemechs, huge two-legged combat vehicles, against other players. Piranha Games developed it on CryEngine and Infinite Game Publishing published it. It first released on October 29, 2012, and officially launched in September 2013.

It suits a particular kind of player. IGN described it as an alternative to twitch-reflex shooters, a game that rewards cautious play, thoughtful weapon use and advanced tactics. If you like outthinking the other team more than out-reacting it, that's the appeal. If you want fast respawns and constant action, the rest of this page explains why it may frustrate you.

Where it delivers: the combat and the mech garage

The strongest praise went to customization. GameTrailers and GameSpot both singled out how much players can change their BattleMechs, and the game is built to feed that. Winning matches earns experience and c-bills, the in-game currency spent on new purchases and on tuning your machines.

The fighting itself held up too. IGN called the gameplay solid, and GameSpot praised both the gameplay and the graphics. GameTrailers, the harshest of the three, still found matches generally enjoyable.

  • Deliberate combat: weapon choice and positioning count for more than reaction speed.
  • A reason to keep playing: every win puts money and experience toward your next build.
  • Factions and planets: players can join a faction and fight for control of planets on its behalf.

Where it falls short: a steep start and early repetition

The same depth that rewards veterans makes the first hours rough. GameSpot pointed to a high learning curve. GameTrailers called the interface cumbersome and said the game did a poor job of explaining its own systems. A newcomer should expect to work things out alone.

Variety was the other complaint. When GameTrailers reviewed it, only two modes were available, Assault and Conquest. The outlet found that matches quickly turned repetitive and that nothing tied battles together. GameSpot also criticized the shortage of modes and of maps built for 12v12 matches.

IGN's main knock was pacing: matches swing between fast and furious and long and drawn out.

The game's own description now lists deathmatch, King of the Hill and Conquest, along with the faction warfare system. That faction layer is the kind of structure GameTrailers said was missing. None of the critic reviews here judged it, though, so it's unclear whether it fixes the problem.

Mixed scores and a rocky 2013

Critics landed in the middle. GameRankings rated it 70.60% and Metacritic 68. IGN gave it 7.3, GameTrailers 6.0 out of 10 and GameSpot 60 out of 100. One critic aggregate, based on nine reviews, came in higher at 78/100. The critic average of 7.8 is calculated from critic aggregates, so it follows that more generous figure rather than the individual reviews.

Beyond the reviews, delayed features, contested design decisions and poor communication from the developers caused growing community backlash during 2013. Anyone weighing a long commitment should know that history. Because the game is free-to-play, it costs nothing to see whether its slow, tactical pace suits you.

Sources

Was this post helpful? No votes yet